“We weren’t doing a good job showing the value.” Where does a new brand find trust when it can’t claim a bestseller like HexClad? Connor MacDonald (CMO, Ridge), Cody Plofker (Advisor & fmr. CEO, Jones Road Beauty), and Connor Rolain (Head of Growth, HexClad) compare a scaled HexClad funnel with one from the weeks-old Winks. Step by step, they trace how each one builds trust across ads, landers, offers, and upsells. Winks has a premium product, yet customers couldn’t see why it was worth the price. HexClad earns that trust before the click, with Japanese creators and a bestseller hook. The weeks-old brand has to build the same trust with a fraction of the proof. Powered By Motion https://9ops.co/motion-runneth Aftersell https://9ops.co/aftersell-mops Haus https://www.haus.io/operators NeonPixel https://9ops.co/neonpixel Richpanel https://9ops.co/richpanel-mops Proppel https://www.weareproppel.com/operators Operators Portal https://portal.9operators.com/dashboard Operators Newsletter https://9operators.com/ Chapters 00:00:00 Winks Is Up “1,000%” 00:02:51 Do We Name the Mascot? 00:08:49 Who Is the Winks Buyer? 00:16:15 A Lander for One Creator 00:22:05 Only 27 Reviews So Far 00:27:06 Supplement Claims Race 00:31:37 HexClad’s Japan Egg Pan 00:37:50 98% New Site Visitors 00:40:55 Upsell Take Rate at 27% 00:45:12 PDP That Breaks Rules 00:51:13 One Product Can Sell Sets 00:54:15 No Ad Works in a Vacuum
Sign in to save notes on this episode.
All right. Welcome to Marketing Operators. We've got a great episode today. We go deep on funnels. Connor Rowlane talks about scaling their Japanese egg pan internationally and now in the US. And Cody goes deep on Winks adjustments. The brand is 4 weeks in, so we're hitting both sides of the spectrum, multi-hundred millions of dollars of brands. And Cody's doing a couple orders a day, which we're all super excited about. We end the episode talking about generalized advice for how can you iterate or improve or accelerate Your new funnels, which is obviously the lifeblood of any D2C brand. So thank you for listening. Let's get into it. Connor Rowland's gonna walk us through sort of step by step some of the, the new HexClad funnels that are scaling this year. We're gonna start with Cody. Um, we tore apart the Winks funnel a couple weeks ago with Varun from AfterSell, which was super fun. It's been— Winks is basically twice as old since that episode. So, um, give us, give us a status update. Where's your time been? What are some of the learnings?
Yeah, you know, I know that Ridge is up 50% year over year. I just want to say since that episode, maybe 3 weeks ago, 2 weeks ago, we're up like 1,000%. So it's not a comparison. But if I sum up the feedback in 3 areas, obviously offer is really important. And with us being a new brand without a lot of credibility, you know, the feedback was like, why am I going to spend the money on this? Right? Like we weren't doing a good job showing the value. So you can, you can do a few things. You can obviously add a lot of social proof. You can make the offer better and go cheaper, you know, on a discount, whatever it is. But you can also educate and provide more value, which is part of a thing we're trying to do. So we're working on a, you know, scientific advisory panel right now to get, you know, to get, you know, doctors and get more credibility. We are obviously, you know, doing a better job. The feedback was like, yes, you have these ingredients, I don't know anything about them. So we built out a big ingredient grid that actually links to like the clinical claims because people in this space, one learning is like they actually really do want ingredients. Like I'm, I'm so usually like top of funnel marketer. I'm like, hey, no one cares about ingredients. They want pro— they want problems, they want benefits. But like when people get to site, they actually very much do want to know what's in it and why those were chosen, especially to help us with, with the price point. And then from a design perspective, like we're obviously going away from kids and stuff, but the branding is still very playful and we'll probably do a fuller like rebrand packaging, right? So many brands do like, you know, to kind of try to upscale it. And I think that's our learning. It's like our, we have a mismatch between our product, which is actually very premium. It's got 3 clinical ingredients. The COGS are not cheap. Like The guys took no shortcuts there, but our branding doesn't, nothing about our marketing shows that. So now it's just like, what can we do? So I at least like changed like the look and feel of our website quite a bit. So I'll just, I'll share my screen and show it real quick.
Is this the homepage that we're looking at?
Yeah, this is homepage.
Okay, so for those listening, I'll talk through it quickly because if you checked out getwinks.com, I don't know, last week, 2 weeks ago, 3 weeks ago, it was extremely playful. Do you guys have a name for the mascot?
I don't know if we do.
You need a name for the mascot. That's number one.
Well, I'm trying to get rid of the mascot. I'm trying to get rid of it.
Okay. Well, if it had a name, maybe it would be working. Like you gotta, you gotta, you gotta fully like anthropomorphize the mascot. Yeah. Um, like dude, you remember Grimace Shakes at McDonald's? I mean, like that doesn't happen without Grimace, the name. Um, that's what you should be going for. Uh, If you looked at the site 2, 3 weeks ago, it was like, it almost looked like an illustrated, like, children's book. It was very cute and the branding was like really well done. This, what we're looking at now, far more elevated. There's white backgrounds, there's more text. It's just like far more premium of a feel. The mascot has been ridiculed to, or ridiculed, subjugated to a much like smaller part of the site, which I think— Relegated. Relegated, thank you. I don't have my thesaurus with me. relegated to a much more unimportant part of the site. So I think that's probably good for, for conversion rate optimization. It looks good. So let me ask you this. Um, are you A/B testing this or are you still in the phase of like, you're sort of, you know, ingesting anecdotal information from people, making gut decisions and just kind of like seeing what these changes result in on like a day over day, week over week basis?
Yeah, we did. We didn't test this. We'll probably get to the point soon where we will, but just trying to get our traffic up a little bit higher and You know, this was just making a bunch of big changes at once that we thought were right. So it was, there was a lot at once, definitely not a scientific way to do it, but, uh, no, no A/B tests yet.
Are you just looking at like conversion rate and CAC then to, to really back into whether or not this new experience is, is performing better than the previous one? Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. We're looking at that. Obviously looking at like cost per add to cart, you know, we're just looking at how many orders we get coming in and is it more than we had before or less?
Yep. I, I love, I think personally, like my biggest thing when you guys first launched was like, I wanted to know more about the ingredients. Like, 'cause I think that's what, like your headline or like at least one of your headlines was like, we're not, we're not using melatonin. But I felt like the narrative stopped there and I was like, okay, well what is it using? And I love how, how much more ingredient forward you guys are being now. Like, I really like this, this 10 ingredient packed in one nightly drink with the pop-outs. I think that's like, it's really helpful for me to understand. And like a lot of the, I recognize a lot of these ingredients and like, I trust this product more just based on, on this section. I think this is, this is really cool.
I appreciate that. Yeah, that was, that was very consistent with the feedback. Some of it was even like, I don't even know what it is. Like, I know that you're talking about sleep. I know there's talking about no melatonin, but like some people, a lot of people know, but some people are like, why is that even bad? I take it. And then some are like, okay, if it's not Melatonin, what is in it? And also even like, is it a drink? Like people couldn't even tell if it was a drink. So obviously that's why we got the image in there. So yeah, I appreciate that. You know, just trying to make it skimmable. This is one thing we're working on that we don't quite have yet, but I think it got missed at the beginning. It's like, so like pain is a lot easier to sell than prevention, but like some brands do a good job. Like IM8 does, AG1 does, is like they're not fixing like it. immediate problem. You're kind of selling a little bit of a lifestyle. And so, you know, our co-founder Curtis, who's like the vision, the product guy, like has this belief, like better sleep is just worth investing in for like your health and everything else, you know? And so we're trying to kind of take some steps to test how that messaging plays and showing just like, hey, like worse sleep is, or better sleep is, you know, has all of these longer-term effects. I don't know how it's gonna do, but it's definitely something from like a positioning side where we're starting to kind of take that direction as well.
So the other thing, so in the spirit of like talking about the full funnel, this makes total sense. Redesign the website to be more premium, be more elevated, be more educational. How has this affected like the ads that you're developing? And also I'm curious how the ways in which you're producing those ads have changed over the last, you know, in the course of the first 6 weeks of the brand.
Yeah. So what we're finding the most success with, I would say, I would say like, you know, we don't have a ton of winners. We definitely have like 2 things that are rising to the top. Number one is partnership ads and I'll show you one. Like we really just got one of our first ones in. And I mean, this is more like partnership ads with like an influencer, larger influencer instead of like a, you know, small tribe creator. But it's doing really well. It's definitely getting a lot of spend, definitely has the best metrics on it. You know, not obviously profitable yet, but like definitely like really strong signs of that. So we're going to do a hell of a lot more partnership ads. I think, you know, like Instant Hydration did from the beginning, like it can be just like a great way to A, get credibility when nobody knows about you, right? Like just obviously clear, you know, influencer marketing and then B, like strong signal to Meta. And then I also think we're going to test diversified personas. And so it'll be some testing. Like we're also going to go, Some of the feedback we got on this stuff was like, hey, it looks very feminine, but like, I'm a guy and I can't sleep either. And this is interesting. I think I said it on the last pod, but like, we're like 60/40 male to female right now. I think a lot of that is obviously because of our ex-audience and stuff, but even our Meta spend is more male. So like, I don't know, like that, that, that we're going to, we're going to see and like really trying to still figure out who the customer is and what the messaging is. But so partnership ads doing really well. And then we're gonna start making more of them. But like the AI animated stuff is actually doing pretty well. The, you know, the songs that people are talking about, like those are doing pretty well. And I think we just have to test more scripts with them.
Cody, can I ask a question about like the persona stuff? 'Cause you guys started off like very specifically positioned, like you were, I think if I remember correctly, it was like, if you're a woman, 40 plus with kids, like this is the product for you. You guys have clearly like pulled back from that a little bit and repositioned to be a little bit more like ingredient forward. And you're kind of seeing who's resonating without like assuming who the audience is going to be. So like, obviously like some stuff about the package, right, is still positioned that way. Like your bedtime bestie, that's clearly positioned for like a female in the like you know, 30 to 40 range, I think. So do you anticipate, like you're kind of pulling back from that a little bit? You, like you said, you're finding out that your demo is maybe a little different than it was originally positioned for. Do you think you'll ultimately like reposition it for a very specific person at some point once you have more data on like who that core buyer is? And kind of also like once you guys get through the, like for the personal network buyers, right? Because obviously that's going to skew things and you kind of need to see like what's the organic Um, demo? Like, do you anticipate you guys almost repositioning it for a specific person again with that data?
And I would say, I don't know, like it could go in one direction where like, all right, cool, this is our customer, right? It's, it is this 40-year-old mom. It is, maybe it's, it's like specific, the whole brand is around perimenopause. I don't know. Right. Or the, or it's, we'll go more general. We actually think that this is a unisex product, which is great. Like that's probably better, larger TAM, right? Like, I struggle with sleep. Like there's no reason that, you know, I can't, maybe it niches down to like, my hunch is it niches down into a little bit more of like a, actually like longevity, like health optimized, but like a little bit more like serious and sciencey and a little bit more of like premium, right? Like we have to go like less playful, more premium, but a little bit more like general there. And then we can have funnels that are talking about the specific problems. That would be my, my guess, my hypothesis. But we're really using this inventory we have for our first PO to, to test. And so that's part of the goal with the partnership ads. It's like, we're going to test some, you know, male health and wellness guys. We're going to test doctors. We're going to test the perimenopause angle. Like, we're going to test a lot of this because yeah, right now we like really don't know. I don't think we I don't know. Sometimes it's easy to be like, and I've talked to a few people like this, like, this is our customer. And obviously everything is about who the customer is. So it's like, this is a problem, but it's like, hey, this is our clear customer. This clearly solves a problem for them. We know it's for them and we're going to go create it for them. But sometimes it's like, hey, this is a problem that a lot of people struggle with. And then we have to go and test into these things and kind of find the product market fit a little bit.
[Sponsor Content] Everyone is talking about AI, but few operators are actually using it to speed up their marketing and make better decisions. At Ridge, we use Runneth. It's an AI brain for the whole marketing team. It watches every creative you've ever run, knows what's inside of each one, and connects it to what actually drove revenue. You can plug it into your Klaviyo, Shopify, Northbeam, your whole Google Drive. It reads all of it. So instead of asking what worked last quarter, anyone on your team can ask for 10 evergreen concepts worth testing before Q4 and get them back within minutes. We use it. HexGlide uses it. Jones Road uses it. It's the best AI brain for e-com brands on the planet. If you don't use it, you're going to fall behind. Go to runneth.com and book a strategy session. Mention Marketing Operator sent you and you'll get $1,000 in free credits.
Like for me, when I'm, I'm much more, I'd be much more likely as a male to buy this product, just seeing the homepage. Now, the only thing now, again, the packaging still skews female, so that would maybe like deter me a little bit, but like, like when anytime I think, especially with just like how many supplements there are out there and how many supplement brands there are out there. I think me personally, and maybe I'm a little like health pilled on this stuff, but like, I really care about ingredients and like, I want to see the laundry list of ingredients and I want to know what's in it, what it does. And I also, the other thing I really like about your, your new homepage is I feel like you've, you've taken the ingredient angle from, or you've, you're approaching ingredients from 2 different angles. Like you have the how Winks helps you sleep better. And I like how you're connecting an outcome to the ingredient. Like calm stress is connected to ashwagandha. Afron is connected to sleep quality. And then you have more of the just like straight up objective ingredient with the popouts. Like I think that's a, that's a cool, I think that's like a really smart way to hit it from, from both angles, like outcome-based and like here's which ingredient gives you which outcome. And then you just have more of like the straight up science, like here's the ingredient, here's why it's in Winkx, here's the research on it. Like I think that's a really smart way to go. Like you're hitting it from both angles and I think different people are gonna care about it. Like some people just want the list. and like the scientific information. And some people are like, I don't want to go all like nerdy on the science. I just want to know that ashwagandha calms stress and, and great, I'm stressed out. So like, I'm now interested in this product.
I appreciate it. Yeah, I appreciate that. All right. 'Cause I don't want to take too long, so I want to make sure you guys get yours. But yeah, I agree. And like, I, again, we don't know, but like same thing. Like I like the product. I think the product is really good. It helps my sleep. Like I don't necessarily, like I wouldn't be drawn to the packaging. I wouldn't be drawn to, you know, the branding. So I think once we determine who the customer is, like, I'm sure that'll change. And if you look a lot, like everyone shared that like AG1 screenshot of like what their initial branding was and like they've had like 3 or 4 over the years. Like it is a very standard thing to do. Obviously, like maybe we missed more than we should have, but it is a standard thing to do. All right. So 2 things that are working well, partnership ads. I'll share one, right? And one thing that I think anybody could do and learn from. So here's one and we'll link it. I'm sure team will link it and everything. But, you know, partnership ads, I think they're great for everybody, but initial stages, because you do get a little bit of targeting signal to Meta, right? You do get a little bit of credibility. A lot of people have told me in the initial phases that can lower CPMs, right? But, and then you just get the credibility and then I'll show you like the lander that we built, you know, and it's just a great way to kind of test anytime you're working with creators, of course, but to like give 'em a brief and test messaging and like see how they're gonna say things. So, you know, it's really just a standard kind of, you know, UGC video was posted as an IG story, you know, initially, you know, and I won't play it with like sound and stuff like that right now, but it's just kind of talking through it, giving, you know, the main talking points. I can share our brief as well. And then it's going, we tested it initially to a PDP. did pretty well, and then worked to spin up this lander. And I think in the early stages, it's something where now we have so few partners, 'cause we're not spending that much, that we can probably build a lander for everyone. And now we have a template. And so I built this over the weekend, took like a day and a half, just like various, as I had time over the weekend. And now we have a template done. And so we can just have a skill in Claude or Codex where it's like, all right, cool, Read, watch this video, pull out the top points, screenshot images from it, you know, put it there. Uh, and so this has helped performance a little bit as well.
So actually one question here before we get too far into it. Um, on the ad we were looking at this woman, very raw. She's sitting in her living room, she's holding the Winks bag, she's talking about it. We've opened up, opened up the lander. Now you've got her name here. Learn how Winks helps Ellen Kim get the best sleep of her life. We've got her featured again. Is she, I saw people discuss this on X recently. Is she a known creator in any way or are you just like—
She's got like 450,000 followers, so she's not like a celeb. Um, but I see— But there's some credibility there. Yeah, I, I would say our, our, our rule at Jones Road, we probably didn't personalize the landers unless they had like a million followers. But you know, we're testing like 10, 20 partners a week. So it's just harder to do and not always worth the uplift, but right, I have seen it even like 150,000 followers, I have seen it work. And we had an ad that was fatiguing going to like a PDP or a different page and we built a 5 reasons why with that creator in it and like just totally turned around performance. So even smaller, would I do it for somebody that size or 50K? very unlikely. Um, but I don't think they have to be like a Tony Hawk celebrity to, you know, to benefit from it.
But then also, I mean, I feel like a big part of just the Wink thesis generally is that with AI and great templates and processes, like you can just do much more than you could in the past that theoretically, like if Jones Road used to do it for people with a million followers, like you could totally justify doing it for your top 40 creators, no matter who they are, you know?
Absolutely. Yeah. What took the time on this page was, was the, was really the design and development of it. And so now that that's done, um, I could build a skill and, you know, very likely have, have Codex or Runneth, you know, watch the video, pull out the top points, do the 5 reasons. Like, yeah, I totally agree with that. So I'll, I'll let you know the next time I, you know, build a page, which will be this week or next week. Um, it should be, you know, Mere matter of minutes. So yeah, I agree with that. And I'll just walk through the template a little bit. Obviously, you know, all the basic stuff like social proof, gotta be very skimmable, have the creator's picture above the fold, obviously have your social proof and offer above the fold. You know, bullets, I think we could have some bolding in that to make it a little bit better. Have, you know, a benefit-driven headline, but mentioning the creator's name. You know, her video's in here for people that wanna do it. Little 5 reasons why section, social proof. I saw this on another page. I kind of picked it up, designed them so they kind of look like Facebook. The other ones that I have on the PDP have actually had like comments and likes on them. I got to add those back, but you know, just a little hack to kind of, and if you can even like screenshot from stuff from Facebook, like even better, wherever the traffic source is.
That's a great one. Zach Stucke's a big proponent of that with a lot of the HoloSocks landing pages, like heavily feature comments from Meta just 'cause like it feels, I think there's, it feels more realistic. It feels more authentic than just like these sort of generic pull quotes that people often do.
For sure. 'Cause it's harder to fake. Yeah. Anything that is like harder to, that the brand can't fake. So yeah. And I think these even could be more real. We just don't have the actual ones on Facebook, but if I did, I would.
I like that you, I like that you put someone as anonymous. That feels, again, that just feels like—
No, I'd rather have it be a name.
I kind of, I mean, like, honestly, I kind of like it because I think some, some people are like super weird about having their name out there. So I could see, like, honestly, to me, it feels more real that 1 out of 4 people would be like, actually, can you just like not put my name up there? Like, I feel weird about that. It actually feels like more legitimate.
Interesting. Interesting. Um, so, you know, we go buy box offer. So this is kind of the offer that we're testing and going with. Buy once, save 35%. Buy 2, get 1 free. Um, just trying to make this look a little more attractive.
Is this the same buy box that you can reach from the homepage as well?
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So obviously in the future we can have different ones and test them, but right now just going with that because like the offer wasn't the main variable here.
And no sub? Sub. Oh, this is both sub.
Both sub. Yeah.
Oh, I see. Okay.
Yeah. Yep. Yep. Um, you know, the same section again. So like a lot of these sections are just kind of reusable, you know, reviews, social proof. So a lot of the, a lot of the standard stuff. Um, again, it's not like— Thank you.
What are, what are his reviews looking like right now, Cody? Like, I, I think that's such a, important part for any new brand is like getting legitimate reviews. Um, and like, are you guys doing things to help streamline that more than like, I, I go, once you get going, right? Like you set up lifecycle marketing and that kind of gets reviews coming in in an always-on way, but are you guys doing anything early on to streamline the reviews?
[Sponsor Content] Before Q4 hits, the smartest e-commerce operators aren't just asking, how do we spend more? They're asking, how do we make every visitor more profitable? That is where AfterSell comes in. AfterSell helps e-commerce brands increase revenue per visitor, contribution margin, and incremental profit by optimizing the highest intent moments— cart, checkout, post-purchase, and even the thank you page. Brands like HexClad, Ridge, and Pela are increasing their AOV across every cohort using these zero-risk upsells. We've tested and they have no negative impact on conversion. It's just more free money in your pocket. And with Rocked Thanks, you can offset your AfterSell subscription. No redesigns, no risky funnels, just better economics. Wanna see how much money you can make with AfterSell? AfterSell, go to aftersell.com/rocketrevenueforecast, put in your numbers and see how much more profit your funnel will make before BFCM starts.
Yeah, that's a really good question. And Connor from Gut Culture, I'm curious, you know, if you guys did anything, 'cause it's tough, obviously. Like we did a lot of early, you know, sampling to people and got some reviews for when we launched, but like we still have probably 27. It's tough 'cause with like a Judge.me or something like that, like it does have to be a verified customer. Right? Otherwise it'll just say like, this was gifted and I think it's better to have verified. So some of it is just naturally having them come in. But I think just in general, like the more social proof, like Zach Stuck has, you know, on Mars Men, they have like so many great photo before and afters. Like they just have so much great social proof. And so I'm trying to think like, what is one of ours? 'Cause I think that's one where you just wanna flood the zone with social proof. And if you look at a lot of these like, DR brands that are doing well, like a Primal Queen or something like that. Like just loads of social proof and like in various different forms. So I think for us, I'm trying, I'm probably gonna do like images of sleep scores and like somebody on X yesterday tagged me in one and I'm just like, hey, can I use that? You know? And maybe we'll do a challenge or figure out like in a lifecycle flow, how do we request these things and incentivize people to generate them? So I'm all for ideas, but That's, I think, a little bit of the challenge right now and we're trying to do more. We'll have creators right now, like we posted for our, in our Discord to have creators do some videos on site, you know? But yeah, all, any ideas, Connor, anything that you've done that has worked?
I wasn't gonna say, I think the Aura stuff is really interesting. I think that's a fun way to like show the before and after because it's not like, I don't know, you can't like really visualize it with someone. I don't know, maybe you could show like, someone looking refreshed versus groggy, but that just feels a little like facilitated to me. I think the Oura, like, here's, here's the, here's my average Oura sleep score before trying Winks and look at it now, it's gone up by 20 points on average. I think that's a cool angle.
I like that too. You know, I really like MudWTR. I don't mean to be, this is such a faux pas. I'm going to talk about another sleep beverage that I have before bed, but MudWTR has a great like rest formula and I was talking to their team about it and like my big The first few times I tried it, I got like 90 sleep scores and I'm like, oh, this feels, it's so hard to like quantify sleep. And like the way you feel in the morning is affected by so many different things. Um, that like the score is a great way. It felt very validating to me in the case of Rest. Again, this was months ago, pre-Winks. So, um, I've got, I'll change my allegiance, but, um, but that was, that was really big for me. The only thing would be that's a really discerning customer. I don't think you're necessarily selling people. Selling to people, or I think it will be much more difficult if you're selling to people who really care about their sleep scores. It might be great, like, validation just to convince the average tired mom to, like, be converting on the product. Because to Connor's point, I don't know how else you show that before and after. Although I'll say one other thing, the image of, like, someone groggy versus someone refreshed does feel a little contrived. But I think it works. I think, like, I think We have to be, at least certain funnels, you have to be thinking about the median consumer when you're advertising. This came up on X again recently. Someone was talking about, um, they don't like being sold to just after buying from a brand. And they said, you know, if consumers don't like this, then why do we do it? And like what every brand will tell you is that the data says that is the time someone's most likely to purchase. And the best thing you can do for your brand is try to get them to create that second order almost immediately. For us, it's like, It's within the first like 7 days of the first order before they even receive their, their first order. Um, we're often trying to drive that second one. So I just think like, we also have to take a step back and make the distinction that like our preferences are not like the median consumer's preferences, just the amount of time we spend on websites and like thinking about marketing. And I do think the like just heavy-handed tired man versus like rested man is an image that could like really, really crush. So I wouldn't write any of that stuff off.
Held off on the sleep score because like Matt originally wanted to do like a better sleep guarantee and stuff. And I was like, I don't know. And this is part of like trying to figure out our persona, but like, I don't know that our customer is like a Huberman optimization. Like, I don't even know that they're tracking sleep scores or wearing an Oura. So I think that'll be interesting and obviously we'll depend on it, but I totally agree with the point of like playing to the middle persona.
Playing to the middle persona and And can the sleep scores simply serve the purpose of showing the before and after that might like appeal to the median consumer?
I was just going to say, and I think that's a good point. Um, and I kind of mentioned about Mars Men, like having different ways to show social proof. It's like, it's not just one in reviews, but there's a bunch of different ways. And there's, there's, there's video, there's, right, there's press, there's your actual reviews. Like there's the before and afters. Like you can just flood the zone and have different ways because one, I might care about one and you might care about a different way a little bit more.
Yeah. I've got one other question for you, Cody, as we like go through the whole site. You know, Taylor Holiday had a great podcast recently about, it was with Andrew Ferriss about how difficult supplements have become. And one of his reasons is because there's nothing defensible about claims. So like you brought up this point, like better sleep guaranteed. And like, you know, I don't know the legal implications of that or what that actually means or whether it can be quantified. And are people, you know, expecting their dollar to be returned if they're not actually sleeping better. It does feel like the supplement space is just so aggressive with claims right now that it is like a race to the bottom of claims. And that's like one of the reasons it's become such a PvP saturated, like difficult market, I think, to launch in today. It's got great economics, but there's a lot of people being really aggressive with user acquisition that often comes down to claims. So I'm curious, will you guys, it feels like you guys are very tempered in your approach to like speaking about the value and Do you see that changing over time or are there gonna be touchpoints like throughout the different funnels where you'll lean into it further? Because I feel like that's, like you're sitting on a lot of opportunity there potentially.
We probably will. I don't think we'll take it as far as some do. And I think building it publicly makes that, you know, makes you have to do it, you know, white hat. So I think we can, we will make claims that we know are, compliant and legal. But, you know, for example, we do have 3 clinically studied ingredients. And so there are, we can make claims because of that. We can make claims for those ingredients. We can't say Winx has fixed this or Winx has, you know, fixes this. We, you have to say supports, but you can, we can say these ingredients have been shown to fix this or do it. Everything else otherwise has to be a support. But if you look at like Rise ads or something like that. Like there's a lot of, like, if you watch closely, like they say supports, like they, they're very aggressive with claims, but they're not saying this fixes it or it cures. Like that's what can get you in hot water. It's, hey, if you have this problem, if you have this bloating problem or whatever, this is a fix. And then they kind of like agitate it hard and then it's, you know, then it's, hey, Rise supports this. So you kind of, there's like a little bit of a gray area where you can get it. And so we will definitely play around with a lot more of that and I think we will need to, to be successful. I totally agree. I think, I think we're too, we're too soft and watered down right now.
Well, yeah, 100%. And, uh, I've obviously not, I'm not advocating for any sort of like real gray or black hat behavior here, never on the Marketing Operators Podcast. Um, but, but there is, there is more to be done there for sure in a very legally compliant way to all the points you just mentioned. So, um, excited to see you guys experiment with that further because I just think there's, there's some meat on the bone.
Well, and some of that is even like, and I don't think we'll do it now, but like paying for and investing in like clinical studies. Like at Jones Road all the time, like every product launch now we do that is because that's what allows you to make these claims. And even, even at Jones Road, if we want to say 8-hour wear or, you know, fixes, help dark circles or stuff like that, like you do a consumer test and you pay 10 grand and, and if it works out now, you're, you are able to do this stuff.
Totally.
[Sponsor Content] You know the difference between hitting your numbers and missing them? Clear signal on what's actually driving growth. It can get really, really noisy. There's so much noise. You got platform data, you got blended data, MMM, all the acronyms, MTA, experiments, all of it, all pointing in different directions. The more you're spending, the faster you move, the more bad signal can cost you. That's why we use Haus and we've been using it for years. That's why the other marketing operators do as well. They're the best tool on planet Earth for measuring what we call incrementality, which we talk about a lot on the podcast. What is the true impact of your advertising dollars on your business? We have causal MMM for channel-level budget calls, causal attribution down to the ad level, and Architect, their AI agent, tells you exactly where your next dollar should go. And the results speak for themselves. StockX saw a 41% lift in IROS using Haus, and you're not stuck with a help desk. You get an embedded measurement strategist who actually helps your team make better decisions. Their whole team is great. We've worked with a lot of them. They are world-class here. Go to haus.io/operators, H-A-U-S dot I-O slash operators, and start backing your budget calls with real causal data.
Well, sweet. We want to call that a wrap on Winks and talk the egg pan funnel from HexClad.
All right. Yeah, so we've talked about this before, but one of the new acquisition wedges we've found success with this year is this new category of products that we initially launched in Japan and some of our other international markets and had some decent success with these products with our retention audiences. And then when we launched these in our paid accounts about 3 months ago, they've really been one of our top new funnels that we've launched. And it's been really exciting for us and it has really just shifted a lot of how we're thinking about promoting more products in our ad accounts. So yeah, I'll share my screen. I can run through some of the creative here, then kind of go through what we're seeing. So first off, in terms of like ad creative, we had a really awesome stack for launch. So we had like 3 different creators that we activated with, you know, doing a mixture of pure whitelisting, which is what we're seeing here, partnership ads, and running these right from the brand page. Funny enough, like the pure whitelisting is what's working the best out of the gate here. This has been our ad that scaled the best. And then we also have a bunch of static ads. This is just one example, like product-focused, you know, I guess you could call it a lifestyle image with the flowers in the background. A few things here that I think make this ad really awesome. One is like, we've never activated with Japanese creators before in our US ad account. So like right there, we're reaching a totally new audience and I can share some data on that. And we're just building a ton of trust, right? Like we don't have, it's a Japanese person talking about these, these Japanese products and there's a ton of trust baked in there. And then the other thing as far as like format goes was like opening with product and then following up with use cases and outcomes. And I think that she did a really nice job of that with both of these products. So, um, that's kind of the format of this ad. And then we, we move on to some of the other creative that we have supporting this. We have a bunch of like lifestyle product-focused static images like this, again, really leaning into like the Japanese origins. And then another thing that we're, that we're pretty much doing with all new products is like just a really beautifully shot, what we call like our hi-fi hype reels, which really sells just the premium nature of this. Um, so I'll play this one as well. And this is one that we, you know, we shoot this type of content for pretty much every single new product we launch.
One of my questions actually, before we get like too far into this, um, cause we think about this a lot at Ridge, the ad we just watched seemed to heavily focus on the rice cooker early on. And then it, and then it did a really good job of hitting the egg pan afterwards. So I'm curious, how often are those things bought together? And then how are you thinking about ad creative that supports each or both of those? The second ad that we looked at was just the egg pan in like that really elevated static image. I don't know what we're going to look at here, but like, how often are they advertised together? How often are they advertised separately? How do people buy that? And then how does that inform like the ad creative that you're building and the way you set up the accounts?
[Sponsor Content] Yeah. We really just wanted to have a mix. And I think the reason we wanted to have a mix, and I actually think this is still generally kind of a slept on reality in the ad account, is that it's not like people are seeing one ad and going to the site and then that's it, right? That's the journey. Our frequency since we launched these ads is a 4.5 on all of our egg pan and rice pots. So on average, someone is seeing 4 to 5 ads, um, when they're in this funnel. And like, that's why we just wanted to have breadth. We wanted people, we wanted some people only focusing on one. We wanted some others focusing on both of them. And what we're seeing is that, and I'll get into this in a little bit here, but like the price point for both of these products is $130 USD. Our AOV in Northbeam on these is like $217. And on average, 1 in 4 or a little bit higher than that, it's like 27% of people are buying both of these products together. So we are, you know, getting a pretty good take rate. on the upsell and we'll get into the landing page experience to kind of run through why that is. And then that's not even including people that are coming in and buying like an additional product as well. And you'll see on the product page, like we are really selling the cookware technology as a whole. So it also makes sense that we're seeing some spillover, but yeah, we really just wanted breadth more than anything. And again, there's like 3 different creators, all with different ads showing different products. And then again, Good breadth of statics. And then we have our, our hype reel here, which I'll play now. So quick, fun, punchy, like music's good. I saw you bopping your head. Like it's, it's like short and sweet to the point. This one's definitely more like value prop leaning early on, but it still hits on the outcomes here. And again, all these, I've just like created this very robust funnel where we have a bunch of different messages, asset types, and some are a little bit more outcome focused, leaning into certain products more than others. And then some are a little bit more like product value prop focused. So we have, you know, this, this very robust funnel now, kind of just hitting people from different, different angles, from the brand, from creators, and it's just creating this like really nice ecosystem of ads. All right. This ad is technically a job posting for Neon Pixel, but, but stay with me here. Neon Pixel is hiring performance marketers, people who actually get incrementality. They understand holdouts, they understand triangulation, And really that's the entire pitch because when you sign with Neon Pixel, these are the marketers that are running your CTV strategy. We've been with Neon Pixel at HexClad for 3 years now, and they really do work like an extension of our team. Live on real living room TV in days, helping with creative strategy, same-day end card swaps, and measurement read in our stack, not just some black box dashboard that we don't really understand or have insights into. And that's ultimately what a managed service looks like when it's staffed by real operators, And real marketers. So whether you want to work on the sharpest CTV accounts in DTC, or you want that team running yours, go to neonpixel.co/careers to apply. Okay. So the other thing, like this is, this is fully an acquisition product, right? On an acquisition funnel on a specific set of products. We are promoting a product we've never promoted before. We are activating with an entirely new batch of creators that we've never activated before. So This has a 98% new website visitor percentage. That's like insanely high. We never see, like, we always, we don't have like a lot of the net new visit percentage woes that some brands have, but like it'll get as low as like 60%, mid-50s at times, depending on the time of the year. So this has like really activated an incremental audience for us through all those things that I just mentioned. And really the message that gets them interested is like, number one bestseller in Japan. Like that's what that creator opened up with. Now it's brought to the States. Like we're really leaning into the social proof from the sense of, hey, these are Japanese products that are selling incredibly well in Japan, which is true. Those are our hero products in our Japanese market. And there's just like so much inherent trust when that's the hook. And then you have a Japanese creator giving that hook. Like I think it really very quickly It's trust, trust, trust is what I wrote in my notes here. Like it really quickly builds that trust. And then moving on to the landing page, which for us is just a product page. Like we might, we probably will develop a landing page to try to continue to scale this further, but like we've just been able to scale it early on without too much fatigue. So we're like continuing to lean in here. But what I like about this experience is, again, we're leaning into like the Japanese social proof in the ad creative really heavily. And then the first thing right under the product name is our reviews. And this is a sticky link down here where we have, you know, a 4.89 out of 5-star review on 103 reviews with a bunch of fresh ones, right? 17 hours, 6 days, 8 days, 8 days, 15 days. Like clearly people are actively buying this and leaving reviews. So we're starting off with like the brand and creator-led social proof. And then we, we hit the website and the very first thing someone can click is this reviews link and boom, now we're hitting them with social proof from our actual customers. So I think we're like just building a ton of trust early on in this funnel. Then going down again, right away, the first thing we say in the product description is already a bestseller in Japan, this evolution of a traditional Tokyo-style tomogoyaki pan, yada, yada, yada. So again, just like that narrative is very cohesive. And then we're getting into like our always-on kind of evergreen cookware technology, right? Like the hybrid technology, the product dimensions, care and use, you know, really de-risking the order with the lifetime warranty. Same thing here. This is all like, I think at some point we'll probably want to do a custom technology section here. Um, but really then leaning into the, um, just the evergreen kind of product page social proof that we have, you know, we have really nice, you know, product hype reel, um, right before our additional social proof sections here. So that is the destination that we're driving to. Let me find my notes here.
You know, one thing I want to talk about quickly, because this is why I asked about how you guys are thinking about the egg pan versus the rice cooker, um, or the rice pan. We think about this all the time and, and, and the rice pot. Thank you. Um, like, uh, I just want to call out that a 27% take rate basically on this upsell is crazy high. an extra $109. Yeah. Um, that's what we're thinking about all the time. And it's a little bit different for supplements, right? Supplements are like, okay, I mean, there are optimizations to make in driving up initial order value, but like a lot of the value you're going to get from a customer is like, you know, from a retention perspective, like you're going to get it over 3, 4, 5, 6 months. For brands like HexClad and Ridge, it's like, we need to be getting value today. And so properly teeing that up at the ad level across like a bunch of beautiful creative, and then driving them into a page where it's super simple to add that, to the point that 27% of people are adding it, I think it's just like one of those things. It's the flow that we try to create across all of our categories. Like, when we think about what is the number one upsell to the wallet, what's the number one upsell to the power bank, to the carry-on, it's just like that extra little thing, and then how do you pull that all the way through from the ad level to the PDP to, you know, we'll still continue to try to sell it in like post-purchase upsells. So I just think for me, that's what really sticks out is like a very nice integration of the complementary products. Yeah.
Yeah, 100%. And like, that was the whole goal right out of the gate here was like, how do we get as high of an attach rate as possible? And it's like, we'll sell them on both products out of the gate. Don't only sell one of the products in the collection and that take rate's going to be way better. You know, I think what's going to be really fun for our retention team as we move into the end of this year and into 2027 is like, we are acquiring now more and more people on products like this that aren't the $700 12-piece set. So I think where we need to take our retention program is really start to treat these segments of, you know, basically cohorting people based on the first products they've ordered, running market basket analyses, running second, third, fourth order analyses to see what are the products that someone that buys these 2 products on their first time order most likely to buy next, and then building like specific experiences for those people. Like, I think that's how we, you know, we, I think for us to continue driving growth in lifetime value comes from treating our cohort more personally and just having more experience that are personal based on the first-time order product that they bought. So again, for us here, like there is no offer on the, I mean, I shouldn't say there's no offer, obviously like the entire experience is the offer, but like there's no discount on our price point. However, this price is much, much lower than our best-selling, like super highly merchandised sets, right? And it's, it's like very easy to go and like click around on our website and see the products that we're promoting the most, right? It's our 12-piece set, our 6-piece set. So even though there is no, there's no offer on, on this in terms of like discount, it's just a lot easier wedge into the brand, especially when you compare it to all the different SKUs that we are merchandising more prominently. And then of course we do have this $30 off offer on the complimentary product. Same thing. If you have the rice pot selected, it's the same price offer on the egg pan. So, and that is really, I think what's driving that. It's a combination of like that cross-sell offer plus the education we're doing in the ad creative that is driving that, you know, 27% take rate on this upsell. 27% of people buying one of them are buying both of them.
[Sponsor Content] Most brands treat customer support as a cost, but with AI, every support conversation is now a chance to increase retention, recover revenue, and grow your LTV. Richpanel doesn't just use AI to answer tickets, they allow operators to run revenue experiments inside your support. You can test different win-back offers on refund requests, subscription save offers during cancellations, and product recommendations that turn chats into sales. Plus, they guarantee you're going to save money. 50% of your support volume automated in 30 days or your money back. That's a pretty good offer if you ask me. So go to richpanel.com/demo. They'll build an AI support team live for your business and show you how it can drive incremental revenue for you.
If I land on the homepage and I go to find the Japanese egg pan, do I land on this PDP or is this a paid specific PDP?
No, you would, you would land on this. This is just the product. Yeah, this is just a regular product page here. Yeah.
You know what's interesting? I don't know how I feel about this personally. Another thing that we've thought about a lot, I think that the egg pan rice pot selector, like it's a, it's very interesting from like a hierarchical perspective where it's like, oh yeah, I don't feel like this is like a variant. I'm on, I'm shopping the Japanese egg pan. I didn't, I didn't actually expect to be able to switch to the rice pot right there. I get that these are a collection so that you can. It makes sense that people are shopping between them consistently, but, um, that's something that we don't do currently. Yeah, we don't do that currently. And I think it's interesting. I don't know if it's right or wrong, but we've always landed on the other side of like, once you're on a PDP like this, like you were shopping that PDP, we can push you into bundles and upsells. But like, we wouldn't navigate someone. We would have it as like a, you may also like section, make it really clear. Like, hey, this is going to be another thing now where I think intuitively, at least in my mind, I think of these like variant selectors as like just selecting variations of the thing that I'm looking at and not navigating to like a net new product.
Yep. And this is like, that's a good point. 'Cause this is very, like, this is the exception, not the, not the regular setup for us. Like if you were to go to most of our, maybe all of our product pages, all of our selectors are mainly variants. It's like you're on the pans for the pans page and it's like 8, like 7, 8, 10, 12, 14. This one, because we do not have a landing page that merchandises them together, we're going right to the product page. And because we're educating folks and explaining both products, we decided to add this selector. So it was all in the same experience. The other thing that we're talking about, and we'll probably do a test on at some point, is what's going to perform better? Is it actually having the cross-sell right here with the offer or Is it simply to have a 3rd variant here that's like egg pan rice pot bundle, and then there's a discount baked into the overall price? I don't know. We haven't tested it. This is working well. So we've decided to just scale it as is. But I think that's probably a future test that we'll run is like this experience versus maybe removing this or not, or we just keep it and it's still there when you have the individual selected. But some people might prefer just to like buy the bundle without having to click this, this extra select button and to get both of them in the cart. So like, that's probably a future a future test here. And then, you know, one of the questions in the brief from Mike was like, what happens if someone leaves without buying? Again, I want to go back to the point that 4.5 frequency on these ads, it's not like someone's only seeing the UGC ad and never seeing anything else. So like we have, I don't know, probably 10 unique creatives in this funnel. So people are seeing a lot of those, which I think is absolutely helping the performance here. We're hitting them with different styles of assets, different messages, multiple couple creators. And I just think that's so important. Like we always have our, you know, we call this like a B-tier launch and like we always have our like content buckets that we're going and producing against. Like we are always doing the hype reel, we're always doing product and lifestyle statics with text overlays. We are always doing creator-led ads. Like that is, those are the buckets we're always filling. And I think it's really important when you look at the frequencies on some of these funnels. And then also of course, you know, we have all sorts of browse and like abandonment flow is happening in email. You know, we are like fully seeing massive lifts with Shopper right now relative compared to our static lifecycle marketing in SMS marketing. So obviously people are like getting pushed into the Shopper experience as well if they browse and they don't convert. And then just in terms of like results and what we're learning early on, like I think I wanted to just briefly hit on like Why are we saying this is a winner? Like what data points are we seeing? So I'm seeing it in like 2 different phases. One is just creative testing, right? Like when we launched this in our creative testing campaign, this had like, like not even a small, like not even a 10% marginal bump against all of creative testing. It was like way, way, way higher than our entire creative testing return on ad spend. So like right away we saw that efficiency signal. I was like, all right, we're onto something here. That was the first kind of like box we checked that we're saying this is a winner. Then over time we've put more and more budget into it. We've spent multiple 6 figures behind this funnel and now we're looking at it a little bit differently. We're saying, hey, now as we're scaling it more, which is like a success metric in and of itself, but how does that efficiency compare to other scaled campaigns? Same thing as we were putting 6 figures of spend behind this, we were able to maintain a strong ROAS compared to the scaled benchmarks. Now, Did it stay where it was in creative testing? No, of course not. As you scale things, efficiency comes down, but the benchmark changes. Now we're saying, hey, how does this scaled funnel compare to other scaled funnels? And we were happy with the efficiency we saw relative to the other scaled funnels. And then last but not least, like huge lift in net revenue on these products since we launched this campaign. So we're looking at period over period since we've launched this, what's the lift in units and net revenue in these 2 products specifically? And then we're backing into like an incremental return on ad spend. Like what's the difference in net revenue divided by the total ad spend? That's a very like vacuum type analysis. Like this is also driving sales on products outside of that, but just looking at like the incremental growth of these 2 products and looking at the IRO as it's also a profitable funnel where the unit economics are working there. So those are kind of like the, The 3 ways we're looking at it is like, how's it looking in creative testing compared to other creative tests? Then as we scale it, how's it looking to other, you know, scaled campaigns and ads efficiency? And then as we also scale, what kind of lift are we seeing just in terms of like blended incremental return on ad spend for these, for this product funnel specifically? And like all 3 of those are looking really strong and giving us confidence to like continue to lean in here.
All right. We only have a couple more minutes. I do want to make one quick point, and this might be interesting for you guys to look at. One of the things that we've found With like new products and specifically new colorways, um, that, you know, like I would imagine a lot of people are clicking on the egg pan ads coming through and purchasing the 12-piece set. Some amount of people. I don't know if a lot is the right word, but, but it's, it's, it's happening some amount. Yeah, for sure.
Yep.
So then we, and I've mentioned this on the podcast months ago, but like, if you fully wait, like if you were to say, hey, I want to look at, um, Japanese egg pan sales and the rice pot sales. over all of the, that ad spend for those products, like it might be an overly conservative way to look at it. We end up having a much lower, like, quote unquote MER target on a, on like a specific product basis, because we know that a lot of revenue is being captured elsewhere. So for instance, we run, let's call it a 2.5x MER, our target MER on an individual product. I shouldn't even say target. Our best launches are like a 1.8. You'd actually expect that they might be a higher MER, that they might actually be more efficient, but that's, they are technically more efficient and the incremental ROAS on the ad spend is higher, but that's just because so much of the revenue is captured outside of like the specific products that we'd be including in the numerator. So it might be an interesting way for you guys to look at it as well.
Yeah. And that's why, like, whenever I'm work— I'm looking at that third, like, measurement model, like just like the blended performance of the business, it's Like that is always the, like, it's a super conservative way to look at it. Like I'm looking at our scaled campaign egg pan and rice pot right now. And, you know, we have like custom LVR events set up so we can go see what other products people are buying. And like, you know, we've sold 48 griddles from this. We've sold, you know, 52 12-piece sets, 35 6-piece sets, you know, 16 knives, 8 barbecue pans. Like, You know, there's all sorts of other orders happening here that we're not even considering in the blended, you know, business unit analysis here. So I think, yeah, 100%, like that, that IROAS that we're calculating is the absolute, like, most conservative way to look at it that you, that you possibly could.
For sure.
[Sponsor Content] People are the most important part of your business and finding real A-players is hard and incredibly time-consuming. That's why I want to tell you about Propel. Propel is honestly the best recruitment agency that I have personally worked with. They are marketing and operations specialists. They source talent from US, LATAM, and beyond for top e-com brands like Jones Road, like many others that you know and love. At Jones Road, we've hired over 12 people through them. We've hired video editors, graphic designers. We have multiple retention managers, creative strategists from them. What I love is not only are they easy to work with, they're quick, but they work on performance. So you only pay a one-off fee only once you hire somebody. You don't have to pay, you know, any retainer, no ongoing fees. Plus every hire comes with a 3-month guarantee. So I highly recommend them. They've worked really great for us. We have a really great team that they've helped us source. Head to the link in the show notes and submit the form to get 10% off your first hire.
So I've got, I've got one last thing I'd be curious your guys' perspective on. Like if we were gonna generalize funnel building advice for people, we've all, we've all, you guys talked about very specific examples for Winks and HexClad. If there was gonna be generalized advice for people who want to turn around, look at their brand and maybe like improve or build out some of their funnels initially, like what might we say? So like, I guess one of mine, and I hit it hard with the HexClad example, would be just thinking about the complementary products.
Yeah.
You have a hero product like the Japanese egg pan. What are you most often selling alongside that? Make sure that's advertised in ads on the landing page. Easy upsell opportunities. You can be value-oriented there, which I think is cool. I think that sort of thing can go a really long way and can be applied across a lot of other businesses.
I, I think for me, me, like the biggest thing, at least if you think about it from like top of funnel to beginning of funnel, top of funnel being the ads, middle of funnel being the lander destination, bottom being the conversion point. Like, again, these ads do not exist in a vacuum. I think too many brands, they're like, oh, we made one ad around this product and it didn't work well. So we're going to write that off. It's like, well, it might've worked if you had 10 different ads, right? Like, 'cause they all do, you know, they are additive, they work together. People are seeing multiple ads and like, You gotta have different asset types. You gotta have different angles. You have to have different value props and creators. And like these funnels work together, these ads work together. They don't work in a vacuum. I think that's like, don't write it off if you haven't taken a strong enough creative swing, I think is the first point I would make. And then as far as destinations go, like you don't need to necessarily have a landing page to test with, right? Like start with what you have. If performance is good there, great, scale it. If conversion rate's bad, like I think that's the signal to go and maybe like if you have a really high outbound click-through rate and good engagement on the ad, but conversion rate's not there, okay, well then maybe you have a destination issue. Like go try to create a landing page. But like I always like to start with just like a really strong breadth of creative. I also think like this is our existing technology, right? Like we're not, this isn't like a totally new category that I have to really educate someone on. So I think that also is a reason the product page is probably working better here. But I would start with those points.
The other one I would add, we did this, we're trying to rapidly increase the rate at which we're developing landing pages. So we're trying to find more reasons to have a landing page or uncover why we might build out a new destination for people. And one of the things that we did was we just began grouping our ads by winning concepts. And so Bruneth does this really well. Bruneth was a part of like this exercise where it's like, let's, um, let's group these things further to figure out what are the value props or the problem and solution messaging that like a few of our winners have in common. We started there and then what we did, and this has just become so infinitely easier with AI, but then we, we did a comment analysis. So we looked at all of those ads and what are people commenting about? What are, what do people have questions on? And we obviously did a review analysis. And so those 3 things was a really like, it felt like we were looking at our ads with really fresh eyes. Like when we go through all of our funnels, there's a very sort of subjective lens that we put them through, which is valuable. And like, there's a lot that can come from that, but we found it to be a very helpful exercise to have like a more objective view of what are people saying, like, let's group these ads and even that, like removing the subjectivity from that, or at least allowing a third-party tool like Run It to do it. I thought was helpful, identified sort of like new concepts or dimensions of messaging that like we maybe weren't thinking about. And then the very objective nature of like, what are people actually commenting and reviewing about this product? And that has sparked a number of ideas for us to continue iterating and launching either new ads or continuing to build new landing pages. So I'll, I'll throw that one in there as well. It's just like, um, further, uh, retrospectives.
But I, but I do think Like to go back to what you were talking about related to our funnel and like the, just like the merchandising stuff. I do think generally people under-index the cross-selling, upselling, post-purchase experience. And everyone's like, how do we find the next winning ad or the next, like, you know, 5% lift in conversion rate or 5% drop in CAC through a landing page? But like often, like you're if you find a winning funnel, like it's often way better to think through like, what's the, how do we extract another $50 to $100 out of this person through email and SMS or like onsite post-purchase experiences? And like, you know, it's always like a size of the prize kind of analysis here to decide where you focus. But like for us, like we, you know, if you were to look, if you were to bucket our first-time orders by average order value, if you were to say like $0 to $200, $200 to $400, $400 to $600 and so on, and then to look at like 12 12-month reorder rates, like they're inversely related, right? Like the lower the first order is, now they don't necessarily back out to overall LTV, but when I look at the, when I know that, and then I'm looking at the AOV on this funnel, it's $217, which is like well below our blended first order AOV. To me, the obvious place to actually go and optimize is like, we know these people are likely to reorder at a higher clip. Like let's go give them the opportunity to do so. in a data-driven way versus let's go source the next UGC ad. Well, why? We already have 4 that are performing well. Like, let's go extract more value out of these people that are already coming in at a really efficient, you know, ad and CAC and all those things. So, um, yeah, I just think like there's nuance here and where you go to decide to optimize the next part of the funnel. It's not always the next ad or the landing page.
Totally. And maybe the way that I would generalize that is just like, Really taking a high-level view of the economics of your funnel. And it's like, where can you improve it? And rather than saying, oh my God, I need to like just convert people with more and more landing pages, or I need lower and lower CPMs or higher and higher click-through rates. So you could, you, it could be as simple as saying, hey, I'm only getting, for Ridge, we, we're like scaling up this $30 tracker card funnel. And the best place that we can create value might not be conversion rate. We're not gonna get, get people to convert at 12%. But can we get a 150% lift in the first 3 months? It's like, that's super, super possible. So, um, all right. I like that one as well. So we've got some generalized takeaways. I like this super fun breaking down the funnels with you guys. I say we call that an episode.
Yeah, this is fun. We should do some more screen share stuff like this.
100%. All right. We'll see you all next week.