Operators Network
Main
DashboardAll ContentTopicsPlaybooksTech StackStarred
Activity
In ProgressCompletedNewsletters147EventsMy Registrations
Network
Meet the OperatorsSocial Feed1716
Shows
9 Operators9 OperatorsMarketing OperatorsMarketing OperatorsAI OperatorsAI OperatorsOperators BuildOperators BuildTitansTitans
Get access →
Have questions? →
9 Operators·Video + Audio·1h 13m·Oct 28, 2026

5-Part Amazon Playbook to Scale & Protect Your Brand Profitably

“If you don’t sell on Amazon, somebody else is gonna sell it.” When should a DTC brand stop treating Amazon as an afterthought? Mike Beckham (CEO, Simple Modern), Jason Panzer (President, HexClad), Matt Bertulli (Founder, Pela Case & Lomi), and Katy Mimari (CEO, Caden Lane) break down the five things DTC brands must get right to scale on Amazon. 1. Always stay in stock 2. Executive ownership 3. Tailor your catalog 4. Protect your reviews 5. Pricing and promotion Amazon drives over half of Simple Modern’s contribution profit, yet Matt and Katy admit neglecting it. Mike’s fix covers five fronts: inventory, ownership, catalog, reviews, and pricing. Even HexClad is still learning, after underinvesting cost it millions this year. Powered By Aftersell https://9ops.co/aftersell-operators Fulfil https://9ops.co/fulfil Richpanel https://9ops.co/richpanel Northbeam https://9ops.co/northbeam Saras Analytics https://9ops.co/saras Postscript https://9ops.co/postscript Operators Portal https://portal.9operators.com/dashboard Operators Newsletter https://9operators.com/ Chapters 00:00:00 2027 Amazon Playbook 00:01:48 Meta CPMs Only Go Up 00:06:52 Mike’s 5 Things to Scale 00:11:36 Never Go Out of Stock 00:16:48 Trevi’s Golden Path 00:26:04 Jason Coaches Katy 00:35:27 You Need a Champion 00:43:44 Amazon Is Your Resume 00:48:53 Reviews & Black Hats 00:56:55 Third Rail of Amazon 01:04:34 Do Cheap Products Win? 01:10:39 OU Football Lesson

0:00
--:--
SpotifyApple Podcasts

My Notes

Sign in to save notes on this episode.

Transcript
Matt Bertulli
00:00

All right. Welcome back to the Operator's Pod. Today I got Mike with me. I have Jason with me. I have Katy with me. We are talking about all things Amazon. This is the like how to win on Amazon in 2027 episode. We're gonna structure this episode for 3 people. Okay? You're probably one of these 3 people. You have the people who are not on Amazon thinking about selling on Amazon. You have the people who are on Amazon, but maybe not doing so great at Amazon. That's me. That's Katy. Then you have the people who are scaling Amazon that want to go faster. We've got something for all of you. Mike's actually got like a 5-point or 5, you know, thing framework that he's gonna outline for everybody. And then we're just gonna break down all 5 of these critical areas that you need to get good at to win on Amazon. This episode is fricking awesome. You need to stick around for the whole thing. If you do not follow us, you do not subscribe to us. Good God, what are you doing? Don't just listen to this one. You should follow us all the damn time. This episode has heat. Let's get into it. See, Jason, you're not the only one that Katy comes after. She's like literally flying to Oklahoma to terrorize Mike. This warms my heart.

Katy Mimari
01:07

Matt, you better say something nice about me right now because they're both giving me a hard time.

Matt Bertulli
01:11

Katy, I'm so happy you're here. This is, this is gonna be awesome. We needed somebody to round out the Amazon conversation that we're about to have.

Katy Mimari
01:17

Well, which is sad that I'm the person that's gonna be contributing.

Mike Beckham
01:20

The, the, the word here is round, uh, Katy.

Matt Bertulli
01:24

Round out. We have to smooth the edges of Panzer and Mike and me. All right. You're here to be the, the, the gentler side of the Operators Pod. Yeah. Okay. So like, uh, for everybody listening, we are talking all things Amazon today. This is my vision for this episode. Mike, Jason, Katy is like, this is the ultimate Amazon, like how to win on Amazon in 2027 playbook. Like that's what this episode is.

Mike Beckham
01:48

Guys, rhetorical question. What are Meta CPMs going to do over the next year?

Matt Bertulli
01:53

Well, I mean, if you're HexClad, they're gonna go down 'cause Jason always finds a way.

Jason Panzer
01:57

Good old days are over. They're, they're going, they're going up.

Mike Beckham
02:00

I'm looking at new accounts. I'm looking at Winks. I'm looking at internal accounts we have. I'm looking at the accounts of other people. CPMs are $50, $60, $70. CPMs only go one direction. They only go up. Meta controls the market. I bet CPMs have what, tripled in the last 6 years?

Matt Bertulli
02:19

Oh yeah.

Mike Beckham
02:19

Something crazy. So it's like, yeah, are Amazon fees up 10%? Maybe. But like, we're talking about CPMs going up 3x. And this is why I think fundamentally Amazon is a better channel than D2C. I'm saying like all the controversial things up front because with D2C, you have a complete dependency on basically a monopoly or duopoly. in Meta and maybe TikTok and their ability to raise prices on you. I mean, there's a reason why these companies are so valuable because the market's like, they can raise prices on, on all their customers whenever they want. And so I think compared to those, like Amazon's been really restrained in their fee increases.

Matt Bertulli
03:03

Jason, do you agree that Amazon is the best contribution profit channel out there?

Jason Panzer
03:08

You know, I could see why, Lou, if you look at it versus retail. Right? Like the Amazon fees are always going to be less than, than the retail margin. So that's, that's pretty simple. Costco is probably an exception, right? Like our Costco—

Matt Bertulli
03:22

They're always the exception.

Jason Panzer
03:23

Better. But I mean, really, like, I think the way to think about it is you want to go where the customer is. And, you know, I don't want to like jump ahead here, but I, since you called on me, I will, and you could always take it back, but like, Whether it's a retail store, you know, or Amazon or your website, you want to be where the customer is. And I think the mistake that a lot of people make with Amazon is treating it like it's different than your website in the sense that Amazon to me is just another store where we want to be because the customer is there and we know how to succeed there. Is to treat it, um, well, right? Like you don't want to have dirt on the floor of your store, right? You want it to be clean and beautiful.

Matt Bertulli
04:15

You need to appropriately resource Amazon for the size of that business that you want it to be.

Jason Panzer
04:19

Yeah, actually, I think we do a bad job of it. And we've learned, we continually learn, you know, we keep making the same mistake that we actually don't, we do allocate a lot to Amazon, but probably not enough. And we've had multiple issues this year that cost us millions by not doing that. We are not bulletproof on Amazon. We are great, but we are not bulletproof, right? We were the number one. I can tell you, like, it's unverified, but I know it's true that we're the number one selling SKU in cookware on Amazon every time they run Prime Day, right? And it's like not even close. When we look at our business, we look at our D2C business, Amazon metrics are always in it. We look at our MER with Amazon. We look at all of our data, you know, everything in our SaaS data warehouse. You can pull it in and out with total or just Amazon or break them apart. And the only other, the only thing that we like really actually do to make Amazon actually be inferior is just a little bit of merchandising, a little bit of merchandising.

Matt Bertulli
05:24

So Katy, uh, over to you then. Um, you Your Amazon business is not a massive part of your business. Do you think this is because you don't focus on it and that you've put other channels first, or do you think it's a category thing?

Katy Mimari
05:38

I listened to everything you guys said, and I mean, I would, I would argue a little bit that like Meta's still driving traffic to Amazon. So even the sellers on Amazon are dependent, right? And handcuffed a little bit to CPMs. We, I do think we're category-driven. I think that if you are something, I think it's Jason said, like you go to where your customers are. And so what we're trying to do is take products, 'cause we've got 15,000 SKUs, right? There's not just like 10 hero SKUs that we get to push. And so we're trying to lean into their registry business. Amazon doesn't have a great experience of browsing. You have to scroll through lots of Right. To find what hopefully is the product like, like Simple Modern or HexClad that has all these reviews and, you know, all the standing behind it. But when you go to like Caden Lane, I feel like part of the experience is looking right through the whole catalog and it's

Matt Bertulli
06:33

discovery.

Katy Mimari
06:34

It's discovery. And I think the same with the phone cases.

Matt Bertulli
06:37

Okay. So like what Katy's getting at is like, there are nuances in category, but if we just sort of put those aside for a second, Mike, are there like, uh, Is there a hit list of basic things or principles that you think people need to know when it comes to scaling Amazon?

Mike Beckham
06:52

I'm going to give you 5 things that you can focus on to scale your business on Amazon. Number 1, inventory. Inventory is the lifeblood. Amazon's algorithm really does not handle out-of-stocks very well. If you want to get placed on the algorithm, if you want Amazon to respect your product, It has to be in stock and you have to make it blend into the FBA system where they can get the next day delivery that customers so badly want. So you've gotta keep Amazon well supplied. If you're not buying inventory where you're prioritizing Amazon, if you're sending them the leftovers, you're not gonna be happy with your results. Number 2, executive thought instead of an afterthought. Your best minds are going to have to be looking at the data. They're going to have to be learning the space that you're in, who Who are the competitors? How are the competitors positioning themselves? How are you going to find the winning path within that? And they are going to have to align the organization around this. If you don't have somebody that's senior in your organization that is really committed to Amazon succeeding as a channel, you're going to struggle because it's always gonna be an afterthought to your D2C offering or your other wholesale opportunities. Number 3, catalog assortment. The best players have different catalog assortments in different channels. Different channels serve different needs, and it makes sense that you're not going to want to sell the exact same thing to Target, to Walmart, to Amazon on your website. We've gradually learned this lesson, painfully learned this lesson, partially due to scrapers and partially due to just realizing customers want different things. You're going to wanna be able to participate in things like Prime Day. We'll get to that. You can't if you're not thinking through your catalog from a perspective of How are we building our catalog in a way where we can serve different customers where they're at, like Jason likes to say? Number 4, reputation management. Amazon is a sort of public ledger. It is probably the reviews that people trust the very most out of anything on the internet. We've all learned you can't trust the reviews on somebody's website. Those are doctored, those are fake. Amazon's probably the one place that still has trust in reviews. So you have to be proactive in making sure that your products are portrayed in the light that you want them seen in, and that means you're going to have to be proactive on reviews. You're gonna have to answer people who have bad experiences. You're going to have to be proactive in motivating and nudging your customers to give you positive reviews there. It's very jarring when you see somebody has 5 stars on a product on their website, but then you go to Amazon and it's 3.5. So you're going to have to spend time on reputation management knowing That Amazon is basically your resume to the customer. Even if they don't want to buy there, they're probably going to go look at the reviews there. And then finally, pricing and promotion. One of the things that makes Amazon go is that they have huge events. You know, people are on there shopping for Christmas. That is going to happen. And you want your stuff to be a part of those promotions. You want your stuff coming across their feed. You're going to have to participate in Amazon's deals. Deal days. It's interesting. Look at a brand like Apple. In the first couple of deal days, Apple barely participated. And you know what? Today, Apple puts almost all of their stuff in Amazon's deal days. The reason is it's just too big of a fire hose to ignore. So you've gotta have a catalog assortment and a pricing plan where you can take advantage of these huge surge days where you can get way more customers in a short period of time than you could maybe get in a month sometimes with your D2C website. So these are the 5 things you can do to make your business more competitive on Amazon. Give it inventory, give it executive thought, make sure your catalog assortment is mindful of different things for different channels, manage your reputation, and then dig in on pricing and promotion because you can do some really explosive things during the promotional periods. We keep saying it on this show, straight percentage off is lazy. The best holiday offers don't just add orders, they grow the order. That's why operators run after-sell at Ridge, HexClad, Pela, Pela, Trevi, and more. Cart rewards, one-click post-purchase upsells, and subscription upgrades grow every order without blanket discounts. The numbers: HexClad adds about $5 per transaction, and Pela drove $80,000 in 6 months from traffic they'd already paid for. Rocked Thanks turns the thank you page into pure profit. With Earn and Save, AfterSell matches those earnings on your bill, and you keep the payout, so the whole platform can run at zero per month. Check 'em out at aftersell.com/operators.

Matt Bertulli
11:32

Look, Mike, I like these 5 things. Um, I think they actually speak to everybody, whether you're on Amazon, not on Amazon, scaling Amazon, or like, yeah, I mean, even Katie, you, like, I'd be curious to hear how you handle some of these things. So maybe what we can do, guys, is just like, let's just pick apart all 5. 'Cause like Jason, you just said that you spent years perfecting these and I think a list of 5, my little brain can get its head around this. So maybe let's start with inventory. Um, the algorithm hates out-of-stocks.

Jason Panzer
12:05

Guess what, guys? If your top, top, top SKUs go outta stock, you are absolutely sorry.

Mike Beckham
12:14

You're gonna misplan. You're going to misplan if you do that.

Jason Panzer
12:17

You are, you are done. You have built a hole. You have dug a hole. That, you know, you're, you, you just never digging yourself completely out of, you cannot take it back.

Katy Mimari
12:29

Why does it matter?

Mike Beckham
12:30

So let me, let me break down the mechanics of this one and why it's so important. Amazon and their algorithm is basically one big feedback loop. As customers see your product and purchase it, it sends a signal to the algorithm and the algorithm, if you're getting good responses from customers, makes you seen more often. And it keeps doing that until you are not monetizing the eyeballs that you're being sent better than your competitors. It finds this kind of equilibrium point, and that's where you stay in the algorithm. You go outta stock and you just drop off the algorithm. Now, when you come back in stock, depending on how quickly you come back in stock, I've seen Amazon's algorithm treat you in different ways, but sometimes you just have to start over. And it actually turns out that when you get submerged 20,000 leagues under the sea, Nobody can, you know, you know where the best place to hide a dead body is? The second page of Amazon. So if, if you fall off the map, the, it is very difficult to get your product back up. You have to start running sales. You have to start putting coupons on your, on your product just to get back to the placement that you already had. So it's not even all the lost sales, it's that then you have really low margin sales. In the weeks that you're trying to get it rebranked where you already were. And the biggest reason why all this is important, by the way, is that Amazon has a moat that no one else can challenge, I think, at this point. And that is same-day delivery. All of these fulfillment centers that took them decades and billions of dollars, it is unparalleled. And so you're not taking advantage of that at all if you don't have enough inventory in the system. So it's not even going out of stock. So think about like this. When you send inventory into Amazon, I send in 1,000 units. Practically what happens is they take those 1,000 units and they break it into a bunch of sub-shipments and they send these sub-shipments. This one goes to North Carolina. This one goes over here to LA. This one goes down to Austin, Texas, so that each of their local warehouses can have some of your stuff. The only way you get to take advantage of 2-day shipping or same-day shipping is if you have your product in a fulfillment center next to the customer. And you know what that takes? That takes not just having inventory, but having enough excess inventory that they can spread it out across their fulfillment centers.

Katy Mimari
14:50

But Mike, what if I am a brand new brand that's going onto Amazon and I have all the inventory in the world, right? Like I can show up and feed it as much inventory it needs, and I send it to all of its different fulfillment centers, but I'm on page 3.

Mike Beckham
15:04

Right.

Katy Mimari
15:05

What do I do?

Mike Beckham
15:07

Well, I think what you can do, there's a lot of different mechanisms when you're first trying to understand what's achievable for your brand. One of the mechanisms is fulfilled by Amazon where, I mean, sorry, fulfilled by merchant. Fulfilled by Amazon is when you send it FBA, you send it to Amazon and they hold it in their warehouse. It's like a consignment model. Fulfilled by merchant is where it's like, hey, I'm gonna ship out this order. Amazon doesn't have any inventory, but I'm gonna try and establish my listing and I'm just gonna try and start getting sales. The economics are not as attractive, but it is one way that you can tiptoe in without just being like, I have no idea how much demand is there. I'm just going to send 10,000 units. And then you're like, what am I going to do with all this stuff at Amazon? So there's ways to tiptoe in. And what I would say, this inventory one, where I see it, that it's the most frustrating. I mean, Jason is running HexClad, which is one of the most successful companies in our space. And he is saying that they had major issues this year. This year with inventory on some of their best products. What you see is like even the very best companies where they have stuff that they know people want, they know that it's hitting good sales rates. They'll, because they're not prioritizing it, they'll just neglect it. So I think that that's where this is really probably the most relevant, Katie. It's not for people who are like just starting out, although you do have to have inventory to even test and figure out what the demand is. It's actually for people that have really good product market fit with inventory in another channel. And they just decide, you know, we want to keep the extra inventory for D2C. We don't want to give any to Amazon. And so Amazon just kind of starves. And as a result, they never have an understanding of what they could even do on Amazon because it's constantly starving.

Matt Bertulli
16:47

Can I ask you, like, do you, I don't know if you guys have a hot take on this, like 2027, do you think it's still a great idea to launch a brand on Amazon or do you think you launch off Amazon? And then move to Amazon?

Mike Beckham
17:01

I think it's a very contextual question to 2 things, the category and how mature it is and your skills as an entrepreneur. So, um, listen, I try to, try to have an accurate view of myself. I would say what we did with Trevi took a top 1%, 0.1% type operator, to pull off. We got in there so late that I think most people would've just lost money and given up. And even then I kind of got lucky that some other people hadn't picked the kind of golden path strategy that we found. And so like, that is a very, electrolytes is a very, very competitive category. Like another way I would say it is, I don't think that I could launch now an adult drinkware and really make it work. Right. And I know a lot about drinkware and I know a lot about Amazon. So I do think some of this is how mature is the category, how competitive it is. When it's a more ascendant category, usually there's more opportunity. Another factor is how much of a factor is China? It is really difficult to build a brand in a hard good category on Amazon when China is all over the place. So, uh, like a really good example for us, we're in backpacks, kids' backpacks. We have the number one selling kids' backpack. And if you look at the best-selling backpacks, there's us at like $50 or $60, and then there's a bunch of stuff that's like literally $7. It's just like, I mean, like I, I pay more than $7 in tariffs. Like, I don't even know how that's possible. It's not possible legally to sell, to sell at that price and for it to make sense. But a lot of the hard good categories are like that. And so if you're competing with the East and you don't already have a brand, I, I don't think you can do it. So, but people have to be realistic about like how gifted are they at it and what is your positioning in the market, uh, whether or not launching on Amazon makes sense.

Matt Bertulli
19:01

What, well, you said golden path. Jason, have you heard this before? Like, what does golden path mean? Like, you,

Katy Mimari
19:07

it's like the Wizard of Oz.

Matt Bertulli
19:09

Yeah. I'm like, what? I've never heard this term before.

Jason Panzer
19:12

It sounds like some kind of road in China.

Mike Beckham
19:14

So I went to South America and a shaman gave me something and during the vision, no. So what I'm really saying here is that in any channel, there are a few different paths to victory and they're usually contingent on the product category and what are your competitors doing. And so in electrolytes, there was a path where we could take the extreme value, really high quality, extreme value path. Nobody had kind of like camped out on that path. But if you look at most of the hard good categories, China has, you know, like the entire nation of China is sitting on that path. And so it's like a, it's a total like, and you can't beat their cost structure. So there are usually in, and sometimes in a market, like the path is, hey, I'm going to be the high dollar person. I'm going to spend more dollar, more money on Amazon ads. I've seen people, their path to winning on Amazon is, hey, I'm going to do a lot of meta spend and it's going to, I'm going to try and break even on D2C, but I'm going to capture it all on Amazon. I've seen people where their path is, I'm going to run a great D2C business and I'm going to do demand capture of just the spillover over on Amazon. And these are all kind of winning strategies. I've seen people that are just really exceptional at how they use deals. They find a way to have their stuff on deal just like all the time. And that's kind of the strategy. They structure their listings where they can kind of always be running deals. So there are a number of different kind of tactics and strategies that you'll see people play, but whether or not a strategy will work for you depends a lot on are any of the other competitors doing that? And do you have unique abilities to go and compete with that? So going back to the electrolyte thing, for example, I saw this like aggressive price path as being available part of the reason it was available is that I have the capital to get my manufacturing costs down really low. And it doesn't matter what China's doing because China's not really in this game very much because it's a consumable. So what one of the things that I'm always doing when I get on advising calls with people is I'm like, you have to be really clear-eyed about what are your skill sets, what are you really great at? And then you have to be really clear-eyed about what is the market on Amazon. And then you're trying to find, I mean, everybody thinks, it's just a red ocean. And it's like, there's a lot of competition, but not all of the water is equally competitive. And you're trying to kind of say like, well, where is the place where I think we could carve out a good business that other competitors are not trying to do? And, and what does that strategy look like?

Jason Panzer
21:51

HexClad is over half a billion a year in revenue now, and I don't think we could have gotten there without Fulfill. Coming in as CFO in 2020, one of the first things I did was figure out how to get our hands around ops. Inventory management, demand planning, distribution. I did not feel confident in NetSuite, so we decided to onboard Fulfill. Not only did it replace our spreadsheets with one system that tracks everything down to the zip code, but it scaled with us as we grew from 2 fulfillment centers to close to 10 and expanded into Canada, Mexico, Japan, Australia, all over Europe and China. On top of that, Fulfill's MCP has been monumental. It gives us a 360-degree view across every 3PL so we can spot slowdowns. And fix problems before they hit our customers. Big dogs like Gruns, Comfort Cuts, Ridge, and HexClad use Fulfill as their ERP. Go check them out at fulfil.io and tell them that Jason from the Operators and more importantly HexClad sent you.

Matt Bertulli
22:55

Katie, if you look at like your categories and you look at Amazon and you sort of listen to what Mike is saying. Do you think that there is like actually room in some of your categories to do this? Like, is there actually a path to, to scale up Amazon in your—

Katy Mimari
23:12

Yeah. I mean, yes and no, right? Like, I agree with what Mike's saying about competing with like even just the knockoffs, right? Like when you're D2C, they're only going to yours. Yeah. When, when you're D2C, they're just going to your site. They're only seeing your your items. And Amazon, even if you're paying for top placement, you're still going to see, right? Like we've got a $36 footie and right next to it's going to be a $6.99 one. So, and they can't, there's just not as much space, right? For brand, for the marketing and the experience in the US. So I think brand is very, very important, um, in that category, but

Mike Beckham
23:52

I'll put on an advising hat. Like Katy, if we were talking about your Amazon business, I think where I would start Is I would say, like you said, if I'm just selling a, a pattern every day of a hoodie and I'm at $38 and all the Chinese ones are at $7, like obviously that's super tough. But for example, holiday, you are coming in with new and cute patterns every year that other people won't have. So like that might be an example of a surface area of like, hey, for Caden Lane, we're actually able to hit special events, special patterns that are here and then they're not because basically while we're in market with that holiday pattern, we'll have a monopoly. We'll be the only one.

Katy Mimari
24:30

So, Mike, it's actually how we started Amazon. So we went to it saying, we don't want to take away from our D2C. And so we did the same product types, but we gave like Amazon their own prints, their own colors, because we thought, like what you were saying, like they'll come to different places for different product. Um, and it did okay, but in the last probably 6 months, we actually started sending over some of our higher selling SKUs there. And volume has picked up.

Mike Beckham
24:58

And it's gone up. So here's one thing I'll add to that, Katy, is that when I say you want different products in different places, I think what you just said, I've, that is generally true. Your best stuff is going to be your best stuff no matter the channel. This is what we've observed. So what you're trying to do is you're trying to figure out how to make it just different enough that it's basically still the same thing, but where you can do different things when it comes to pricing is, is pretty much what we've Oh,

Katy Mimari
25:23

you think Amazon should be less expensive than DTC?

Mike Beckham
25:27

DTC? It, well, it depends. Like, uh, as an example of a strategy that I, that I might run if I was doing pajamas, uh, or holiday pajamas on Amazon, like what is your typical retail price for pajamas?

Katy Mimari
25:38

$36.

Mike Beckham
25:40

Okay. So like I might put 'em on Amazon at $49.99, 40 days outta the year. Bring the market down. And then on Prime Day, they're 30% off. And they're not that different in price than my website, and I'm making better contribution profit, but I'm getting deal placement because they're 30, you know, they're 30% off. And so like, it's an, it just is an example of a strategy that's, that's different.

Matt Bertulli
26:04

Jason, I wanna get you in here because I think like we started out talking inventory, now we're talking catalog and merchandising and product channel mapping. How, how do you guys do this at HexClad? Because you don't have 15,000 SKUs.

Jason Panzer
26:17

Matt, what I really want to do is advise Katie on how to run her Amazon business right now.

Katy Mimari
26:20

Okay.

Jason Panzer
26:21

She's clearly doing it wrong. Okay. You need to treat your Amazon business the same as your DTC business. Okay. You need to put all your best there. Okay. And you need to give people, give the consumer the choice for where they want to shop. And that's it. You just got to let it go. You just got to give it away to the universe and let the customer Make the decision. You are going to be way, way more successful. You're going to sell way more and all this, people worry about cannibalization, right? People, well, I'm going to cannibalize my website. Absolutely not. It's just the conversion rate increase is worth it. It will absolutely, like we've seen this. So we did our own natural holdout test for this because in 2020, we had no inventory to put on Amazon and we had no Amazon business. You know what happened? People were buying our product and reselling it on Amazon. And then in 2021, we finally had enough inventory to start selling on Amazon. And the only difference that we did was we did not sell our 13-piece set as a set. But we sold everything else, individual pans, 6-piece pan set, 12, uh, 7-piece pan set, 6-piece pot set, which again, now number 1 SKU on Amazon. We, we, we don't treat it any differently. We just, we just do it. We just do it great. We put it all there. And, you know, your point about not being able to shop, like the storefront isn't great. Yeah. You know what? The storefront isn't great. It's not as great as your D2C. You know what though? It's good enough. It's good enough for people who already went to your store or just know who you are to go in there and buy all of your stuff. So just like give it to them, let them buy all of your best stuff. We make— there's zero difference between hexclad.com and Amazon, and we're going to sell 9 figures on Amazon.

Katy Mimari
28:22

Okay. So then Jason, because I mean, think about it, like one One color of a body style has 6 different sizes associated with it. And I can't, I mean, that, like, sending it to Amazon and all, which is what we do, we do FBA right now, but I have to be selective. I can't give everything. Do you think the magic is in, like, should we ship some of it direct and then ship some, or, like, where do you draw the line, right? Do you take 20% of your SKUs? Do you take 50% of SKUs? I mean, I truly don't have hero SKUs.

Jason Panzer
28:56

Right. You have way more SKUs than we do, which makes it difficult. You don't have hero SKUs like we do, but you do know what sells best, right? And so, I mean, you want to make the most money, right? So, like, put the stuff in there that sells the best and stop worrying. Just stop worrying about it cannibalizing. You know, when we were at your house for the offsite for the mastermind, which was amazing, a few months ago. One of the things that I took away from that in hanging out with a bunch of the people there, the smartest people there actually all agreed that worrying about cannibalization is a losing battle.

Matt Bertulli
29:36

Generally not worth it in most brands, in most businesses.

Mike Beckham
29:39

The main, the main reason you have to think about it honestly is the other wholesalers. Like where you, where you really have problems is when Amazon's pricing and Walmart's pricing are conflicting and they get into a scraper war or, you know, Target or whatever. And you can get into these doom loops. If you just have a D2C business, I'm in agreement with Jason. People get, but they get so protective of it. And I think you're right, Jason. I think that you have the unique seat of having really seen the data, but it makes sense logically. There's just a certain number of people where it's like Amazon has their trust and they want it quick and that's how they wanna shop. So Katie, tactically with you, I've, I've actually got a suggestion. So you might have like in, let's, let's say pajamas, you might have a bunch of SKUs, 50 SKUs for one set of pajamas or something. Right. And because you're so distributed, what I would still do is I would lay out my demand by size. And I would probably say my top 30% of SKUs, I'm going to have in FBA, and then I'm going to support with FBM on everything else. Because you're right, I don't think you can send everything in, in apparel. Um, I've talked to some other apparel brands that I advise, and this has been my exact advice, is that you, you do a blend where you're offering FBA on the highest velocity stuff, but then you're supplementing with Fulfillment by Merchant on all the rest.

Katy Mimari
31:05

Which I feel like I've seen more often on Amazon, just as a shopper.

Mike Beckham
31:08

Well, you, well, it, because people have the same problems you do, you know, it's just like, in that you don't have the money to go big on inventory everywhere.

Katy Mimari
31:16

Okay. But for the record, y'all are making it sound like I'm like completely bombing Amazon. We're profitable on Amazon. It's just—

Matt Bertulli
31:22

No, no.

Katy Mimari
31:23

The complexity that's there. Like I do feel for brands that are struggling with like, how do I get this started or not? Because it, I mean, it's a, it's not just as easy as you spend some money and you get on page 1. You've got to have enough reviews to compete with everybody. And then people talk about how do you get these reviews and what are like the hacks to get them? I mean, it's hard to get on.

Matt Bertulli
31:46

What you're hitting on is important is that like, if your product is highly style driven, like you're like, not only does she have a lot of SKUs, like Pela runs into this problem too. Like we have a lot of SKUs and those SKUs are largely driven by like weekly design drops. So it's like, yes, on one hand, Katie, you probably have like business as usual, evergreen prints that do well all the time, but then the new stuff is coming every week. And it's highly seasonal. So it's kind of like, I think with what Mike is saying on sizing is actually, is directionally correct, but I can see Katie where it's also difficult for you guys to say like, I don't even know if this is going to sell that well. Right? Like I haven't even launched it on my site yet. So like, how do you manage that style of business on Amazon? Is there is a degree of difficulty that's higher. Mike, my question, and this might, this might, I'm going to ask you because I think this might help Katie maybe, is, is it not true That as a brand, you can also get your warehouse FBA kind of approved. So like if Katie can ship fast enough, can she not be her own FBA fulfillment center? Most AI tools right now are all promise and no delivery. You know exactly what I am talking about. Super fancy launch videos. This is why I'm loving what Rich Panel is doing. They have AI and support smashed together, made it practical, made it useful. Made it valuable to brands today, not on some future promise. And instead of asking you to spend weeks writing prompts and uploading help docs and babysitting, they flipped the whole script. Their AI builds your support team for you and everything it needs. I've watched it. It works. It's freaking amazing. Rich Panel even guarantees 50% of your support volume will be automated by AI within 30 days or your money back. I call that a no-brainer offer. The pricing is also kind of wild, about $0.20 per conversation instead of most other vendors being like $1 to $3, which is a little nuts. If you are interested, go to richpanel.com/demo, not for some generic demo, but to actually book a call and watch them build your actual support team.

Mike Beckham
33:47

You can, it's just a really high standard. Um, so you really have to have a pretty developed logistics game to, or a 3PL that does. And, and there are some good ones out there that do it. Um, so like, that's definitely an option as well. I, I think, listen, if you listen to this show, you're an entrepreneur and like, Guys, this isn't that complicated. It's bullets and cannonballs. It's like you test, you test as inexpensively as you can, and then you chase. And like, so get it up, you know, like you've got a new thing you're dropping, you don't know how much people want, get it up, get it up as a fulfilled by merchant and see if people buy it. Oh, they're buying it. Okay. Lean in, send some in, send a couple cases in. That goes well, you know, double down. So I don't, I don't think it like breaks any of like the principles that we have learned and operated our businesses on over and over again. It's just another channel, and often people don't realize what their return potential is on that channel because they're not investing in it. What you wanna do is be investing enough to understand how attractive it is as an investment opportunity compared to the other things. So Katie, like you're saying, you know, is Amazon, is putting more inventory in Amazon more attractive for your business than investing that capital in an additional line of new designs for holiday? I don't know. You know, like you can't know, but there is a way to find out. And that way to find out is experimenting. And that's what you hope is that your team is making these decisions with all the information of what kind of returns are possible across all of the different marketplaces. And so anyway, that's the way that I think about it.

Matt Bertulli
35:27

So We've been talking about inventory and then like catalog and merchandising, which are clearly like those 2 things are very linked, right? Like what you list, how you list it, all that good stuff. Mike, can we go to the second one, which is data competitors? Like, I forget how you framed it, but like, I'd like to hit that one 'cause I think it also helps tie all this together.

Mike Beckham
35:48

So this, the second one is executive thought instead of afterthought. And You have to have a champion of that channel who's willing to think deeply about it and has the organizational authority to actually do things. Otherwise, if it's a director and that's the only person that's really thinking or caring about Amazon, then they're just gonna get overruled over and over again. And it's kind of like we had a conversation recently where we talked about marketing And McCoy was making the principle, the, like the, the idea that basically whether it's a VP of marketing or the CMO, they have to report to the CEO because it's the only way that they really have the kind of organizational authority that they need. I think this is the same kind of idea. If you don't have somebody that's directly reporting to the CEO that's thinking hard about Amazon, you're going to get what about what you would expect because there are so many people that are going to wake up and all they're going to think about today is how much am I selling on Amazon? And that's, Uh,

Matt Bertulli
36:51

Jason, it sounds like, uh, when you made a mention that you just lump Amazon into D2C, like into your D2C channel, you're like, this is performance in the business, which then means that that's solving the thing that you're saying, Mike, which is like Jason's obsessing over the whole number for D2C and Amazon. Whereas like, I think, uh, my downfall on Amazon has always been, it, it has been treated as an afterthought. Like I, I'm a D2C default. Meta ads first operator, Katie, you're probably very similar. And I just never had a person that like owns Amazon in the same way.

Katy Mimari
37:26

Mike, when would you, so we use an agency right now to, to manage our Amazon.

Matt Bertulli
37:30

See, that's the difference.

Katy Mimari
37:31

Okay. Well, let me ask a question. I have a very good question that Mike's going to answer and change my life with Amazon. When, at what point or what revenue numbers do you actually hire that person? Because you're talking about a very high level person. to come in and run Amazon? So is it when you hit $1 million, $5 million, $10 million, $100,000? Like, when do you think somebody should just own Amazon?

Mike Beckham
37:55

I would say that you as a CEO should be thinking, giving some executive thought to it. If, even if the answer to that is, this is why we don't sell on Amazon, like the strategy, your, your holistic market strategy has to be built around the major players. If it isn't, then like, what are you even doing? It's like, Okay, in a world that Walmart exists, in a world that Amazon exists, where do we fit in? How do we eat? And so like, I think that it starts with like, one of the biggest mistakes I see leaders make is that they'll have like an intimidating subject and they'll just want to offload the thought. It's kind of the same thing with AI. Like what AI I've really learned from 6 months and whatever tens of billions of tokens I've spent is that AI can execute almost anything. It can help you think through almost anything. You cannot offload thinking. If you try to offload thinking to AI and expect to get good results, you're not going to do it. And so too often the reason why people will go and hire an Amazon agency or they'll do some of this stuff is because they just don't want to think about it. They don't want to do the hard work. And I strongly recommend against that. Now, if you're like, hey, I want to learn and I think I can learn faster working with an agency or work like, that's a Great point of view. So I think it really depends on the leader, but it starts with, you've gotta have a growth mindset that if you don't really understand this and have a point of view of like where your organization wants to go, have an understanding of the marketplace, then expecting people under you in the organization to do it is unrealistic. If you try and outsource the thinking, you're going to get market results or worse. And that's, you know, you don't wanna be 50th percentile on Amazon. Because 50th percentile isn't.

Jason Panzer
39:36

I just wanna pile in on this thought about, you know, what do you do with agency versus build it? I don't think it's about what is your business now. I think it's about what can your business be? What do you want your business to be? You know, Amazon is like a third of our D2C business, right? It wouldn't be. if we didn't really try hard, you know? And we used agents and agency for a very long time. We still use agencies. It's like, but you've just gotta build, you need the right amount of resources. I literally texted my VP of ops like on this call saying, we're not investing enough in Amazon, right? Like, we're just definitely not investing enough in Amazon globally. And it's a third of our D2C business. And even if it's only 2% of the business right now, I bet you it could be 15% of your business. It doesn't necessarily have to become a third, but I think it could be 50, could definitely be 10%, right? So plan to say to yourself, hey, I want Amazon to be 10% of our business in a year and a half.

Matt Bertulli
40:43

Black Friday and Cyber Monday are coming. Are you ready? Not in the normal marketing calendar offers prep sense. I'm talking measurement and attribution. Are you even going to know what winning and losing looks like when the big Q4 season hits? The reality is the businesses that win set up their measurement solution when the times are slow, not the night before the big weekend. There's a reason for this. You see, with Northbeam, you're getting a totally independent, completely new set of ad performance numbers with infinite lookback windows. That means that the longer that the data grows, the more valuable it becomes. So when CPMs are spiking in November, you will know precisely where every dollar is coming from while your competitors are guessing. This is important. Black Friday is won in the summer, not the day before. Book a demo with Northbeam today. The link is in the description. Go check it out. All right. So Jason, you're saying a third of your D2C business is Amazon. How do you guys, like to what you're telling Katie, how do you guys set targets for that? Like who, who decides that? How do you decide it?

Jason Panzer
41:44

Well, it's just a part of our budgeting process, right? We, we, and that's be— and because we treat it And as basically a part of our overall business. Of course, we model it out from the bottom up basically by SKU, right? But we just, we kind of think, we look at what is the share of our— you do look, we budget top down and bottom up, right? You start with top down and say, what do we think we can do this year? And then how do you build it from the bottom? And so we will kind of look at it and say, all right, where do we look to go this year? And then what is our, okay, what percentage of is typically Amazon in, you know, based on our history or historical data, and then build that up, you know, from the bottom. So for us, it's not that complex in the sense that we just, we have a lot of history in doing it. I think for Katie or someone else that's say newer to the game, I think it's really, you're taking a swag at like how, where you want to be in a couple years and you have to run to get that and you have to know that you're going to be wrong. You're just going to be wrong. All models are wrong, but you just got to kind of like, you got to take a guess, an educated guess that is, and then get after it. And you know, you are invest— you have to invest. Mike calls it growth mindset. I just think you have to look at this and invest for a little bit of a longer time horizon. None of us are public companies yet. We don't have quarterly earnings to report. And you just, you gotta take, um, there's gonna be some risk in doing it, but you, I think in the end, you know, we can get to a certain level and, um, the demand is there, right? We talk about it being demand. I think the demand capture on Amazon, it's going to happen. We all talked about how much we're all spending on D2C and then we're just priming the pump for Amazon. Like the pump is primed, Katie. The pump is primed.

Katy Mimari
43:39

Yeah, no, I agree. And I think there is just some people that Like to buy on Amazon.

Matt Bertulli
43:43

Oh, there's no question. It's like half of all online commerce. So like, uh, and some categories bigger than others, like no question. Can we, okay. So like, let's, speaking of people, let's talk, uh, reputation management. Mike, you, you kind of hit this as number 4. Um, this was the only reason, guys, I put Lomi on Amazon was that people were going there and I'm like, I don't wanna sell Lomi on Amazon. I can't. It's a device with a subscription, but I'm like, but the fricking review farming and the, like, everybody's going there to see if we're a real boy. And like, that is why I went there. I hated every minute of it, I'll be honest. Uh, but it was important. So talk to me about reputation management. Let's start, Mike, with you, and then we'll kind of go around the horn and this concept of Amazon as a ledger.

Mike Beckham
44:30

Amazon's kind of like a message board where you're gonna get talked about. And whether or not you choose to have any agency or influence and how you get talked about is up to you. So like, if you don't sell on Amazon, somebody else is gonna post your product and they're gonna sell it and they're probably gonna sell it at prices you don't like and it might not actually be your product. Right. And so like the surface area for your product to attract unfair slander is very large if you choose to not engage on Amazon. And we know that a lot of people, like when they're thinking about a product, like I don't even know how many times I've pulled out my phone and when I've seen a commercial for something or whatever, and I've just pulled it up on Amazon to see what are the reviews, you know, and what's the velocity? Like, are people actually buying this? And maybe that's because I'm in e-commerce, but I don't think so. I mean, like, I think My wife does it. Um, so I, I think that like you said, Katie, there's a lot of people that are just spending a lot of time on Amazon. This is not like a controversial take. Like if we looked at the percentage of minutes on the internet that are being spent on Amazon, it's not trivial. And a lot of those minutes, they're looking at things like reviews. You need to be proactive. If nothing else, then you control the narrative. So like, let's go back to the example of, do you have to make Amazon and selling on Amazon a huge priority? Not necessarily, but you're definitely going to want to stand for a certain type of price point, and you're definitely going to want to have brand registry, and you're definitely going to want to try and have some agency over your reviews and how those show up. Even if you don't want to sell a single thing on Amazon, you want to do it just because that is one of the, like, points of truth that people that see your meta ad or thinking about buying from you are also going to go and consult. So even if you just view your Amazon listing as kind of like your online resume, that's part of your marketing budget, you should spend some time thinking about what people are going to see when they go. I mean, like, I don't know what percentage of people do this, but even if it's 5 or 10%, that's not trivial in the way that that could impact your numbers, just investing the time to make sure you're presenting the front, uh, you're putting the right foot forward to customers when they start to, uh, investigate your brand and want to learn more.

Matt Bertulli
46:48

Okay. And Jason, uh, has this been true for HexClad? Like when you guys look at Amazon, um, like you guys are a big brand, you're in a lot of places. Is what Mike's saying, is that also apply to your business?

Jason Panzer
47:01

100%. I remember standing at a Costco roadshow booth and one of the people that was watching the demo pulled up Amazon. looked at our stars right there in front of the sales guy. Okay.

Matt Bertulli
47:19

That is the perfect example.

Jason Panzer
47:21

It's that important.

Matt Bertulli
47:22

That's the perfect example. At Katy, it's like, uh, it, I, I, I just, I don't know how you're thinking about this, but for me, I'm thinking of Pela and it's like, we never really treated Amazon that way. Uh, we kind of ignored it actually. Like,

Katy Mimari
47:35

it's like our pet project. I hate to say that, but I also have written down poor Kristen. When she comes back on Monday, I'm gonna be like, these are all the things we're doing on Amazon right away.

Jason Panzer
47:46

You gotta do Mike's 5. Like, this is so epic what Mike came up with here. I mean, you have to do them all. You need to like get unleashed. It's like Project Mike 5 and get after it.

Mike Beckham
48:01

Over the past 6 months, I have spent literally tens of billions of tokens, and one of the things I've worked on the most has been building an analytics foundation for our business. And you know what all of that has taught me? It's that unless you have someone that is a psychopathic nerd that's willing to go in the weeds for months and think really deeply about every aspect of APIs and structure for your analytics, that you should be going and buying from a provider who's doing it for you. What I like to say is that just because I can make a burrito doesn't mean I'm gonna stop eating at Chipotle, and neither should you. You should be buying from someone who every day is putting in the work, And gathering the context of how to do this with excellence like Serra's Analytics. Stop building custom pipelines and start making better business decisions. Head to serrasanalytics.com today to start your free trial.

Matt Bertulli
48:51

All right, so Mike, let me, let me just ask the, like, the obvious question for people listening, 'cause I think we've all, you said Amazon is like this ledger and, you know, D2C can be gamified and All I've ever heard is all these black hat tips on how to get reviews on Amazon and talk, talk to us all about like, how do I go about doing this in an above board, not illegal, uh, don't get my ass banned kind of way?

Mike Beckham
49:17

Amazon reviews. If I had a dollar for every time somebody had asked me about how to get more reviews or to get their reviews up on Amazon, then, then I would have, uh, I don't know how much money I'd have, but I'd have more than I have today. And Uh, I will, I will just make a few statements. The first is one of the things that makes reviews on Amazon difficult is that there are black hats. China has a very broad ethical interpretation of what competition should look like, and there are lots of people that are willing to pay people all over the world to come and attack your listings. They're willing to pay people to, uh, give them, uh, falsified reviews. I would assume this is one of the places where Amazon is employing AI the most. We had a situation where we track our reviews every day and we just saw like 8% of the reviews just went away. And when we looked, most of 'em were negative. And so it's like, I don't know, Amazon I guess was probably like taking some farmed negative reviews out of our listings. But we know this is going on. And so if you're a good actor and you're in there, it's like, well, how do you compete? Here's just kind of the principle. The line is Amazon wants the reviews to be truthful, and when you're paying somebody, they're not independent. And so when I started selling on Amazon years and years ago, it was like you could give somebody a free product and be like, I'm giving you this for your unbiased review about my product. And obviously, like almost everybody who got a free product would give you a 5-star. And so Amazon realized this is a bad idea. They ended that. And now it's like, this is supposed to be a non-compensated review. So the principle is that it's an honest review. Now there is a huge spectrum of how aggressively you can go after honest reviews. Like one example is, can you put in inserts that encourage people to leave a review? Yeah, you can do that. Is that, does that create some risk? Yeah, that creates some risk. Can you put an insert in that says, I'll send you a $50 gift card if you leave a review? No, you should not do that. Do Chinese companies do that? All the time. So, uh, should you proactively try to reach out and try and connect with anybody that leaves a negative review? Absolutely. Should you challenge any negative reviews that you get on your listing because they're actually due to something that FBA messed up? Absolutely. Should you try and find ways that your D2C customers who also shop on Amazon could be encouraged to go to Amazon and tell people about how they feel about your product? Absolutely. Like you should be employing every method possible, but this is such a pain point for brands and it's a little bit of a black box. I tweeted about this last week. Amazon is going to start selling the ability to run advertising campaigns just to get reviews, which is both very smart and super infuriating. So like it is a major pain point, but I, when I talk with brands about this, You just need to develop a comprehensive strategy to get the maximum number of satisfied customers sharing their experience. And that's kind of the line for me. And you know what? Some people are comfortable with more gray in their hat than others. I tend to be pretty white hat, but it's pretty nasty out there in the world of reviews. There's some truly nasty stuff. Sean called me a few months ago, Because they had the number one selling power bank on Amazon and they were just getting blasted with 1-star reviews because, yeah, because China had, you know, China had kind of owned power banks. And the, like, in my experience, a lot of internet, the international sellers can sometimes work as a cartel. And it's like, I get it. Everybody's trying to compete. They're trying to find any alpha there is, but there are certain product categories where it's very difficult to go in because you'll get, you'll get teamed up on. So I would not, I would not minimize any of those things. If you work at Amazon and you're listening to this, it is very encouraging to the selling community and very important that you guys continue to police that, especially in a world with bots and AI, because, uh, this is probably the single biggest complaint of legitimate sellers is that they're not playing on a level playing field.

Matt Bertulli
53:31

Jason, have you ever been, uh, 1-star review bombed at HexClad? I feel like you would also be victim to this.

Jason Panzer
53:37

When we started out, we had a lot of bad reviews. Um, and they were, they were because other people were selling our product and then the buyers were unhappy and then they were leaving bad reviews. And so we had like a big, and so it was analogous to, to, to the, whatever the bots or whatever. So we, we had to really just get after the problem, you know, and like fight for it and, and deal with Amazon and. We've had, we had like a lot of people working on this. Um, and ultimately I think I, we've turned, it took us a while and then we turned the corner and wound up in a place where we have excellent Amazon reviews because ultimately when you're great, you know, the cream rises to the top, right? So the cream is going to rise to the top. And, but you have to fight, you do have to fight through all the nonsense and allocate, uh, the resources to do it and just understand. Yeah. How reviews work on Amazon.

Matt Bertulli
54:35

Okay. Can I ask you guys this question then, Jason, on this point? What, what do you mean by allocate the resources? Does somebody at your brands own reputation on Amazon? Like, does somebody obsess over this at HexClad, at Simple Modern?

Jason Panzer
54:48

Well, there was a time where I was obsessing over it with, with an agency and people in our customer service team. So our customer service plus the agency we were working with. And just me pushing everyone, like we just made it one of our organizational priorities to like, you know, to improve this situation. And, and, you know, it took time, but, but it worked. And there's just, there's a bit, it is a, it is a frustrating game of whack-a-mole that you can win. And I'm not talking about going reviews. Like we really, we really didn't do, um, we've never really done a lot of like trying to go and get reviews. I think our velocity has been so good and our product is so good that we're very fortunate in that way, but we have been. you know, the rear guard action against all the junk that comes in. Like there, there are, there are ways to work with Amazon to get these things taken down.

Matt Bertulli
55:41

Yeah, I think that's actually a key point. Um, we got hit by this on Lomi too. Lots of people were buying them in other channels and then selling them on Amazon. And that's what was killing us is like, and they, and they were selling fake things too. That was a whole other problem. So love that, Jason.

Jason Panzer
55:56

Postscript 2.0 is the AI retention platform built for Shopify brands. And AI is the product, not the feature. Unified profiles. Every subscriber is one person across SMS, email, and orders. So the AI works from the full picture, not a fragment. One-to-one experiences. Instead of messaging to a segment, each customer gets their own message, timing, and offer. Infinity testing that never stops. Copy, timing, offers, sends, all running continuously and compounding. So every send Is better than the last. The point isn't automation for its own sake. It's incremental revenue you weren't getting before. Go to postscript.io for retention that runs itself. I just got hit with one of these. I can see how that would have closed me with an upsell. It was like hitting me with an upsell. Like I absolutely knew I didn't want this upsell, but I could totally see how this would close people. It was insane.

Matt Bertulli
56:55

I wanna wrap things up on this 5th and final thing, which is pricing and promotion. And my God, if the, I feel like this is the third rail of Amazon and, uh, I just wanna, I want you to like break it all down for me. How do you think about pricing, promo periods, channel conflict, everything when it comes to Amazon? How do we do this right?

Mike Beckham
57:14

The first thing to say is that the, the calendar of how people shop, Amazon has a lot of influence over it. The holiday Turkey 12 period, for example, Amazon is gonna be a dominant force. Walmart is gonna be a dominant force. Target's gonna be a dominant force. And obviously D2C matters, but like we're still not that big a percentage of the volume. And interestingly, as you get closer and closer to Christmas, we've, we've looked at this as we look between our channels, the closer and closer you get to Christmas, the less relevant D2C is compared to all of these different wholesale channels. So you're, you're gonna have to consider what Amazon's doing. Perfect example of this is Prime Day. Where's everybody going on Prime Day? They are going to Amazon, but also they are more open to kind of sale messaging than almost any other time of the year because Amazon is spending a lot of money programming them to think that way. So we've seen brands where they use Prime Day and they're not on Amazon or they're not pushing Amazon, but they use Prime Day to push people to their website, but they're still piggybacking off of Amazon's strategy. We've seen people like Jason, and Jason can speak about HexClad's results, but Prime Day is a massive accelerant to what HexClad is doing. I think especially like consumable companies, I think about David at Mary Ruth Organics, like they rack up so many subscribers on Prime Day, like literally tens of thousands of subscribers. And you just think about that when you run some of these businesses, how hard-fought a single subscriber is. Through Meta or anything else. So the deal days on Amazon are a unique opportunity. And whether you're trying to sell on Amazon or you're trying to sell on your website, uh, I mean, even Target and Walmart are thinking about what is their strategy, what is their response during Prime Day and during these periods. So you should be thinking about it too. I think on an everyday basis, the 2 issues that come up the most commonly are, is my pricing on Amazon going to somehow take away from the brand? And the bottom line is no, this is the spotlight bias that we talk about all the time. If you've got something on your website at $50 and somebody sees it for $45 on Amazon, they don't think, oh, this is really a $45 item. They think, huh, I can get it $5 cheaper. That's great. And we overestimate how much people think about us. You have a lot more leeway to change pricing Uh, on different channels than you might think you do. But with that said, other wholesale channels, this is the big behemoths, the Costcos, the Targets, the Walmarts, they all are trying to say to the customer, we've got the best deals and they do not like it when you sell for a higher price on their channel than you're selling on Amazon. So if you're in other channels like that, you're gonna have to be really mindful of either we're running promotions at the exact same time. Or we have channel differentiation with our products where we can run these products on sale on Amazon because they're not in Target, they're not in Walmart, they're not in Costco. So these are the big, I think, challenges that I see people thinking through. And it's definitely the challenges that we've been trying to think through for our brand. But I will say like the deal days are fantastic with Amazon. I think for most brand owners, like they're just a boon because Amazon spends a bunch of money getting people ready to buy.

Matt Bertulli
1:00:41

So Jason, how do you guys deal with price, Amazon, Amazon pricing, D2C pricing, Costco, anything else from a channel conflict? Like you don't have huge amounts of SKUs, so this clearly is something you guys manage. How, how does it work at HexClad?

Jason Panzer
1:00:58

There definitely is channel conflict, buy box issues, uh, issues with other retailers. Being unhappy about pricing. And it's this kind of thing is just, it's kind of nature of the beast and it's going to come up. We've had to make some changes to modifications to what's sold where. We're very mindful of the pricing. We know that sometimes it's going to cause a stir somewhere and we're just kind of like, oops, sorry, you know, oops, right? Like it just happens. We, but we, we definitely, um, we believe in taking advantage of the deals, right? I think you're, you're just like leaving money on the table by not doing it. You know, you got to play the game in the store, whatever the store is, right? So Amazon is, it's, is the store and you just got to play Amazon's game on your website. You got to play their game with Costco. You got to play their game with multiple channels. You're always going to have conflict. You know, there's perfection is the enemy of good. And you just kind of like, you, you know, you work your way through it, but you got to lean in the best you can on, on every channel.

Matt Bertulli
1:02:13

Okay. So Jason, like when Prime Day hits and you guys do something on Amazon, do you then also do the same thing on your D2C? Do you give Amazon the edge? And then can I also ask the follow-up to that, which is like on Black Friday, how do you manage the promo between D2C and Amazon?

Jason Panzer
1:02:32

Yeah, in those cases, these are 2 totally different stores, right? They're 2 totally different customers and 2 totally different channels. So no, you don't have to match any of that. You don't have to match it. You know, you just do. But the thing is, like, we got to have a deal. By the way, shout out Marty Sullins. Okay. Marty is an OG big dog. And 3 years ago or 4 years ago, he was the one saying, guys, everyone should be doing deals on their website on Prime Day. It was like when the first few Prime Days came out, right? Right. Not a lot of people were And now everyone does it, right? Like that was Marty and we all do it. And, but we, we just have different deals. We don't, we don't care. Like Amazon is like, you want to shop? Great. We even like would try sometimes try to drive traffic through our D2C messaging to Amazon. So you have different deals and also Amazon is only a couple of days and the prime time sale could run. Run longer, right?

Matt Bertulli
1:03:31

So, so that's the key. You cannot call it a Prime Day sale on your site. They will send you a cease and desist. Have the receipts. Uh, you have to call it a Prime Time sale and it needs to be like, which makes it in the eyes of the consumer, that's the same thing. Uh, but don't get sued. So Jason, thank you for saying that. Um, Mike, actually, Katy, have you, have you tried to lean into Prime Day? I guess as a brand, because like you still have an Amazon business. Do you guys actually push hard?

Katy Mimari
1:04:00

Like on our own website during Prime Day? Yeah. I think Amazon spends so much money priming the customers to get ready to shop during those days. You're a fool if you don't take advantage of it, um, on your own site. It's, and for us, I mean, we run it both ways. Like we run it on Amazon. And then I think because our, maybe because our brand has enough power behind it, they realize not everything is on the site. So we see an increase in site traffic anyways, um, on those days. Yeah. And for sure conversion and we change it up, right? Like the deals are different.

Matt Bertulli
1:04:34

So Mike, can I ask you like a very pointed question that like just true or false? Do you think that you need to be the lowest price in a category if you want to win the category on Amazon?

Mike Beckham
1:04:42

So here's what's ironic. That is the perception of Amazon. It is almost never the case. Like, yes, go look at the bestseller list. Almost always the number one performer is not the lowest price. It is a common misconception about Amazon. I mentioned kids' backpacks. We are the number one kids' backpack. We are between $50 and $60. The next highest price is $30. If you go and you look at the top 10, the average ASP is like sub-$20. And it, it makes sense why, like if you can sell Jason, like on your hero product, what is the ASP?

Jason Panzer
1:05:22

What is the ASP?

Mike Beckham
1:05:24

Like average selling price.

Jason Panzer
1:05:26

Sorry, sorry, sorry. There's a lot of acronyms coming at me these days. Um, it's $399.

Mike Beckham
1:05:30

Okay. Some of your comp— some of the competitor products that are trying to compete on price, what are, what are their average selling prices?

Jason Panzer
1:05:38

Yeah, they, they, they could be lower. Yeah, they could definitely be lower. Yeah, like how much lower?

Mike Beckham
1:05:42

Like what are some of the lower prices?

Jason Panzer
1:05:43

Uh, higher, maybe $349, maybe $299. You know, yeah, it's all, all

Mike Beckham
1:05:50

just take the $2.99 one. It's gotta sell 33% more units just to hit the same kind of productivity for Amazon that Jason's pan can. And the higher your price is, the more, a lot of times the more margin that Amazon is getting on the deal. And so, because they, they take a cut of things. So when you start like actually doing the economics and thinking about how it flows to contribution profit, Like Amazon loves selling high-priced items, but they know people love cheap things. And so what you really tend to see in most categories, like if you go and look at electrolytes, who's going to be at the top of electrolytes? Well, it's going to be Liquid IV and Element, right? And neither of them are known as like, you know, the bargain option, but they've built the brand equity. So typically what you see in most categories that are like really big categories is you see like a dominant brand at 1 or 1 and 2, 1. And then you will see somebody who has really attacked the Amazon channel with a really high quality product at a really sharp price point that's able to be 2, 3, 4, something like that. So like I said, there's a lot of different ways to win on Amazon. And if you've got a, if you're building a great brand, man, you should be crushing it on Amazon. Jason should be the example. Sean should be the example of guys who started D2C, And have absolutely translated that, uh, on, onto Amazon. So the, the price thing, if you're just trying to launch a company and you're trying to compete with people that are at low price, man, that's, that's tough. Yeah, totally. But if you've got a great brand growing, you'd be surprised at how much demand will, will exist on Amazon that you can tap into.

Katy Mimari
1:07:29

I officially have FOMO on Amazon. I, I know what I'm working on next week.

Mike Beckham
1:07:36

All right. Well, Katy, in exchange for coming to Oklahoma, uh, and, and sitting through watching us beat your football team, I'm going to sit down and talk with you about Amazon. We are gonna, we're gonna figure out how to double that business.

Matt Bertulli
1:07:47

I will say like, Katie, the, yeah, I think you and I have talked about this maybe in New York, is the people who went on Amazon are just like the people who went on DTC. They just have a level of obsession over this channel, uh, internally. And like we, we say like things like resource allocation and focus and all that. But honestly, the people that crush on Amazon, they're just relentless and they're just obsessed over it in the same way that you or I spend a weird amount of time thinking about ad creative. Um, I think that that's like, that holds true to me and that all the tactics and all this stuff that Mike is going through is like, this is knowledge that's available to everybody. I think it is just a question of seriousness and obsession.

Katy Mimari
1:08:27

I think that applies to everything in business. Yeah.

Mike Beckham
1:08:31

Yeah. And, and I think that doing this show makes it clear that like the people that are really successful, they've just thought really, really deeply about a thing. They've thought really deeply about the meta algorithm. They thought really deeply about offer and conversion rate optimization. We have not talked about offer, and I will just say this, offer really, really, really freaking matters on Amazon. Really matters.

Matt Bertulli
1:08:54

How is that different from price and promotion?

Katy Mimari
1:08:56

Yeah. 'Cause you just told me that you increase your price, right?

Matt Bertulli
1:09:00

This is the difference between offer and price though, Mike.

Mike Beckham
1:09:02

Well, like as an example, like a tactic that we've used that people can feel free to steal is like, let's say you have a listing that's got 20 variations. You got a water bottle and you got 20 variations. You can put 10 of them on deal on Prime Day and not put the other 10. And it turns out that a pretty big percentage of the people that come into your listing because they're looking for the sale. Once they get into your listing, they decide they actually want, you know, the tortoise water bottle and they buy that at full price. And so it might look like, oh man, you're really taking a hit on margins. You're 20% off on Prime Day. And you're like, yeah, but actually our margins were not down that much because we blended it out. And so like, you'll see things like this all the time, but there are so many different ways that you can kind of intelligently— Amazon's just full of levers. Like you get in there and it's just like a big control room full of levers. There's all this data, there's all these different things you can pull on. And the more time you spend in the room, the more you start to get ideas of how to pull different combinations of the levers and that the best operators are able to walk into that room and they're able to turn that into profit.

Matt Bertulli
1:10:04

I'm with Katie. I am just like, I want to go obsess over Amazon right now. So I think before my head explodes and before my iPad pen runs out because I've been writing so much, maybe we just call it the pod, guys. Like that was That was awesome. Mike, Jason, thank you for schooling me.

Jason Panzer
1:10:20

Love having Katie on the pod. I love giving her a hard time because she gives me a hard time off camera, but love Katie. You're my fave. You're always welcome.

Katy Mimari
1:10:29

Aw, thanks, Jason. Yeah.

Matt Bertulli
1:10:31

Hell yeah. Thanks for being here. And since we got some of the best in the game here, uh, Mike, maybe why don't we kick us off with The latter, the last group.

Mike Beckham
1:10:46

Okay. You want to scale your business on Amazon. So I'll start here. OU used to have a head football coach named Lincoln Riley, and when Lincoln Riley was at OU, we had a top 3 offense every single year, and we had like a bottom 5 defense every year. Unbelievable. He leaves for USC. We hire a new coach, Brent Venables, who's a defensive coach. Now we have a top 5 defense every year. And we have a bottom 5 offense. What's my point? My point is the reason why that happened at OU is that we've had 2 head coaches in a row that have focused kind of all of the resources towards one side of the ball, and then the other side has suffered. And many of the sellers that I see that think their Amazon business could be bigger or isn't as big as they want it to be, it's because they are not devoting the resources. They're not giving the executive thought. They're not giving the inventory. They're not taking time to formulate a strategy. They're picking pricing just based on D2C considerations and not marketplace considerations. So if you wanna grow your Amazon business, you have to prioritize it. This is not a channel where you're gonna be able to just show up. I mean, maybe if you're Jason, we'll see, he'll talk about it later, but you're not gonna be able to just show up and money fall outta the sky. It is, in my view, the most Darwinian competitive arena in the history of man. There are 10 million different people that have signed up to sell on Amazon over the history of their company. It's probably even more than that now. And you are walking into that arena. Yeah. If you just kind of stroll in there without a plan and without some serious reinforcements, it's probably not gonna go very well. But with that said,

Matt Bertulli
1:12:27

that's been my approach to

Mike Beckham
1:12:28

Amazon. Yeah, exactly. And how's that going?

Matt Bertulli
1:12:30

Like no reinforcements.

Mike Beckham
1:12:31

Right.

Matt Bertulli
1:12:31

Like, can I just throw it at the wall and see if it actually works?

Katy Mimari
1:12:33

Well, it's all coming together now.

Mike Beckham
1:12:35

What? What? What if we sent our crappiest stuff, all the inventory we can't sell on the website? What if we just sold that on Amazon? Would that work? Like, this is the kind of stuff that typically people do. You're gonna have to bring your A-game to compete on Amazon. But listen, here's the upside. There is not a better way to make money in the world. I'm convinced of this. Like, I have sold, I, I have sold everywhere there is, guys. There is not a channel where you can make better contribution profit than Amazon. In my opinion, because your ability to control pricing and your ability— the marketplace gives you kind of unparalleled historically latitude in deciding how your product is going to be marketed and how it's going to be priced. And so if you can do it successfully, I mean, Amazon is our biggest contribution profit generator. They're not over 50% of our revenue, but they are over 50% of contribution profit. It is a lot easier for us to make contribution profit on Amazon than it is in Walmart, than it is in Target, than it is on our website. So it can be done.