Why lower AOV and a disciplined P&L saved this brand from the brink. Steven Borrelli (Founder & CEO, Cuts), Mike Beckham (CEO, Simple Modern), and Matt Bertulli (Founder, Pela Case & Lomi) unpack how Cuts reached $60M without outside money, then nearly went under when tariffs hit at 145%. Steven walks through the layoffs, the first raise, and the comeback that followed. Selling 50K joggers sight unseen gave Cuts confidence it hadn’t earned. Steven explains how a lower AOV cut customer acquisition costs by 65%. Now Cuts is betting on elevated menswear priced below luxury labels, where winning products draw copycats. Powered By AppLovin https://9ops.co/applovin https://9ops.co/applovin-paid-growth Alia https://9ops.co/alia Walmart https://9ops.co/walmart AfterShip https://9ops.co/AfterShip Chapters 00:00:00 Old P&L Mistakes 00:03:04 How to Read a P&L 00:05:59 Cutting From 65 to 6 00:18:13 How Cuts Started 00:28:21 One Fabric to $40M 00:34:27 50K Joggers Unseen 00:44:26 When Ego Took Over 00:51:54 $600K a Week in Tariffs 00:56:59 Going Viral, Then $6M+ 01:05:09 Right Foot, Left Foot 01:14:03 Taking Names in 2026 01:22:19 Titan 10 Questions
Sign in to save notes on this episode.
Steven Borelli, CEO, co-founder of Cuts Clothing, $0 to $60 million your first 3 years. And you recently said sometimes you pull up your old P&Ls just to remind yourself of all the things you shouldn't do. What are all the things that you've done that you shouldn't do that you're telling everybody listening to this they should never do?
Yeah, when we first started the business, we, you know, we, we were at $180K, then $10K, and then we got to $60K during the, the COVID rapid growth. And one of the things we, We just, we really only looked at, hey, was ROAS good and did we hit our sales Shopify? We didn't have a senior CFO at the time. We had more of an accounting manager who was in that role and he couldn't look at what was coming next. And we really didn't understand that your contribution margin had to pay for all your fixed costs. And it sounds so simple, like talking to you guys, I'm almost embarrassed to say that, but things like making sure your cash flow and your future inventory buys are going to be covered by by the contribution margin were the, the things that really helped us understand how to grow the business the right way and understand where is revenue coming from as well.
I don't think that's, uh, that rare, honestly. Like, you think about it like, hey, I'm supposed to start a business. I've got stuff, I sell it to people for more than I bought it for. Like, this is good, right? And then you run a business and you realize like, oh man, you've got inventory and you've got taxes and you've got cash flows and you've got payables. And all of a sudden, like, even though I'm selling things for more than I bought it for, like, wait, why is my CFO telling me there's no money? Or that like we have negative money. Like, how is that even possible?
Yeah.
And I know the last 18 months have been quite a ride for you. You have an awesome mantra that you put into effect in 2025. What was the mantra?
In 2025, we were coming off a bank failure, then tariffs, and we had to massively cut our overhead, um, because we were staring down 145% tariffs. And we said, you know what, this is gonna be the year of the cockroach, which is, you know, when you're at your house and you, you see 'em, you just, you kill it. It's, you just can't kill 'em. You can't kill
a cockroach. It's like Chinese New Year has animals associated with it. E-commerce New Year has like, yeah, we have our own thing. And it was, '25 was definitely the year of the cockroach.
I remember we were on the phone talking like, you know, how do you deal with this when you lose 20% of gross margin? And for us, it was extra bad because we were importing, uh, in, in and out of Mexico. So we had already received the goods and every order in that May period was 145%. We had like a $600K weekly tariff bill. So it was either we shut off the app. Or it was, we were in an impossible situation, uh, from a cash flow perspective because a lot of people, a lot of brands had accepted inventory in the US, tariffs happened and they said they held their boats coming from China or Vietnam. But for us, we had already received the inventory and we weren't paying tariffs before. Now you had to pay the previous tariffs plus an increased amount. So your P&L just got destroyed overnight.
Let's do this for everybody listening. Let's, uh, actually assume that even though they're listening to this, they may not know how to walk through a P&L specifically, like an income statement.
Mm-hmm.
Let's just do it.
Okay.
How do you walk through an income statement? Okay. Top line, that is what we're selling. Then what are you looking at next?
So I'm looking at gross revenue, then there's shipping.
Hold on, stop there. Gross revenue. What makes up gross revenue? What's the difference between my, my total revenue and gross revenue?
Gross revenue can include shipping income. It's before discount, which is the big thing.
Yeah.
Right.
Um, and a lot of people, when they look at their Shopify, depending on what setting you have, it can have gross revenue, which, you know, in the e-com game, a lot of people offer 50% intro offers or bundle pricing, and that gross revenue can include that captured revenue before discount, which is kind of, is not revenue you're actually receiving in your bank.
Does it include taxes in the gross revenue?
In Shopify? I actually don't know the answer to that.
This is something to look out for though.
In Google Analytics, it definitely used to.
Yeah.
You said like $1,000 in revenue used to be like there's taxes in there. So it's like, it's not revenue.
Right. That's one of the reasons I mentioned it.
It does include taxes.
It does.
As an example of a gotcha, it's like they're collecting that revenue for sure, but you're never seeing that. That's getting remitted to the states. And so it's just, it's, it's another one of those things that can kind of throw you where you think there's more money coming in than there is. Okay.
So shipping revenue and then shipping cost. That's another big one that comes out of gross revenue.
Okay.
Because you'll have, some customers will pay for shipping, some will, uh, that you'll have, that if they're over $150 for us, they get free shipping. Uh, and then, uh, you have to look at your, the big one is that is ad spend. What, you know, what, how much you, uh, spent to acquire the customer. And then for us, we have an average, which was a big unlock, an average fixed cost per order. So that's everything else. That the business, uh,
you do that on an order basis?
On an order basis.
Oh, interesting. So you don't do like, uh, net revenue, it's like gross revenue and net revenue? We like to do it both ways. Okay.
We like to know like, uh, on an average basis how much it costs from an internal perspective to, for, for that order.
Okay.
So to kind of crystallize what we're saying, you start out at the top of your P&L and you have how much money came in.
Mm-hmm.
And again, some of that can be money that's not going to you, for example, like taxes that are collected.
Mm-hmm.
And then you gotta take out COGS, obviously COGS, uh, cost of goods sold, your manufactured cost and, and the tariffs to get that stuff over here, that's going to be a really significant line item in your business. You're going to have your acquisition costs. But the point that you're making, and I think that this is the thing that can trip us up, is that you have a lot of fixed costs, which are like your salary and the salary of your team. And maybe if you have rent for an office or for a 3PL or any other costs that you have that are associated with the business that aren't specific to an order, that you have to kind of account for those when you're thinking about your economics.
Yeah. One of the, the beautiful things about tariffs in this situation is we were forced to just, we ha— we had to cut, uh, we went from 65 employees down to 20, and then we went down to 6 during the year of the, the cockroach.
So you went 90% reduction in headcount in how long?
It, this was over like a year and a half.
Wow.
But, but from, uh, when tariffs hit, it was like 20 to 30 down to 6.
How did that feel?
It was, I, I remember I, I talked to my, it was pretty much the guys I started the business with and like 3 others. And I said, hey guys, like, this is gonna be tough. Like, we're, we're on like death's doorstep, more or less. But we've come this far. We're not gonna, we're gonna give it every shot we have to get over this. I think I actually called you and we, we had a conversation of like, hey, I was talking to a, a bankruptcy lawyer to kind of understand what our options were. We were really, really close. But through that, we really learned what the business actually needs to run. We got rid of our New York store. We got rid of any complexities in the business, NetSuite. We renegotiated everything with our, uh, agencies that we work with. And I just said, hey, here's the cost we can pay, take it or leave it, uh, or, you know, you're, you're, you're not gonna be our client anymore.
[Sponsor Content] Matt Bertulli: All right, here at Operators, we talk to dozens and dozens of brands and DMs and texts every single month. AppLovin is now a permanent fixture in their channel mix. And if you haven't tried advertising on mobile games, You have to, especially as we head into Q4, especially as we head towards Black Friday and Cyber Monday. At Pela, this was the most incremental new channel that we tested last year. Its self-serve ads manager is now open to everyone. They are offering you $5,000 in credits when you spend $5,000. That is a dollar-for-dollar match. And they'll give you another $1,000 when you create your account and launch your first campaign on the first day. Every single one of us is Always looking for new places to put that next best ad dollar. It is just one of the laws of DTC. We all need new reach. We all need new customers. If you haven't tried AppLovin yet, this is an incredible first shot. And free money is almost always a good choice, guys. Come on. We use it. Our friends use it. Go give it a shot at applovin.com/9operators.
So you found a whole new level of fiscal discipline when you realized We may go bankrupt.
Yep.
And walk us through some of the really high leverage things you did. You mentioned 'em generally, but get specific. Like obviously your headcount had to come down. Mm-hmm. You had to say like, who are the absolute core team we need to run this business? What else did you do?
We, we, we had been working with a few agencies for, you know, 5, 6 years. We just said, hey, for the next 6 months, you're gonna work for us for free. And, and we just said, hey, uh, that's how it's gonna be. Either let us walk. We're out of the contract or you're going to work for us for free. And to their credit, a lot of them that are still working for us said, hey, we're going to bite the bullet for 6 months. That was a big one. And a lot of those guys I owe a lot of gratitude for. We had a couple bills from China and Shawn actually connected me with his in-house counsel and we just renegotiated the, the, we were on 90-day terms. We said, essentially, we're going to give you 50% of this bill. And if you don't, we're going to move to a new factory. And they were able to take it. One of the beautiful things was I was on the news, so we would just send, we wouldn't even explain the story, we would just send the news article to them and say, with a little note of our request, and a lot of our partners and agencies were like, yep, we understand the issue and we're willing to, you know, have a short-term negotiation of our current billings.
Can you tell us, 'Cause you're talking about like G&A or overhead, OpEx. Yeah. How much of a percent did you manage to decrease total G&A in this, in this time period?
It was like 80%.
Whoa.
Yeah, it was massive.
And what do you aim for? Like when you think as a percentage of revenue, where do you guys try to live? Yeah, that's a great follow-up.
We, we went from payroll of about, uh, 16% of revenue to about 4%, and then G&A was, uh, Like, uh, around like 11 or 12% after that.
So what's total OpEx today? Like if you were to say like, this is, this is, and what do you think a good benchmark is?
It really depends on the business you have. So like a high e-com business that's running ads that doesn't need a lot of staff, it could be 10 to 15%.
Okay.
Um, but you know, if you're running like a sales organization and you don't have ad spend, then it might be like, you know, 30%. So it really is business dependent.
Okay.
But this stuff matters. I mean, most businesses are gonna run between 10 and 20% EBITDA margins, right? I mean, occasionally you'll see people that get above it, but in e-commerce, I think that's typically the range that you see. And so when you're talking about going from, what'd you say, 17%? Yeah. Yeah. If you go from 17% to 4%, I mean, it's like that's 13% that just falls to the bottom line.
Oh yeah.
And like, I think what the tariffs did is it, inserted a whole nother line item of unexpected costs for most businesses and really forced them to do exactly what you did, which is look hard at their cost structure because most businesses cannot absorb a 10% increase in costs, right? And still be profitable. And certainly can't absorb—
We lost 20% of gross margin. Yeah.
And you can't, you can't absorb that, right? Because you'd have to be at such high margins beforehand to absorb that. We had a similar deal where Our tariff bill just for 2025 was, um, $11 million higher. And, you know, $11 million in additional cost, that's gonna hit anybody no matter what your business is.
You were posting your numbers in, in our chat group. I'm like, I don't understand how your business works anymore.
Yeah. Now, did I get an $11 million refund from Uncle Sam? Yes, I did. But, uh, yeah, I mean, like, I remember you mentioned us talking during that period and there was, there was one day in particular I remember where I was at one of my son's soccer games and I'm walking around and I had 3 very depressing phone calls in a row. It was like Steven, and then I, I think I talked to Sean and I talked to a couple of other people because it was just, everybody was triaging. I was talking to Jeremy from Kitsch.
Yep.
Nobody knew exactly what was going on. We were all triaging. But what's so inspirational about your story is the way that I would say that was a catalyst that's going to propel Cuts into the future.
Yeah. And one other thing we did was we actually increased ad spend during that time.
Yeah.
Because, uh, we were able to, like, when we were on our big growth trajectory, uh, we would talk to like PE banks and like, all right, if you want to do the next fundraising or sell, you need your percent of ad spend to come like closer to like the 25 to 28.
You know, I love this rule. Just like everybody makes up rules. Those guys just made that crap up.
And it was just BS. And it's like, I mean, you guys talk about this all the time on the pod, but it's who can actually afford to spend the most is, is gonna grow. So we actually were able to increase it back to the high 30s, um, during that, 'cause we, uh, decimated everything else in the P&L, and that allowed us to grow the business, especially this year in a big way.
It's interesting when you think about your P&L, like one way you can think about it is like, okay, well, what are all the things that have to be done? And so you kind of work downwards from that into who do I need to hire? But if instead you think, Any dollar that I spend on people has to have this amount of sales return. I've gotta be able to, if I've spent $100,000 on this position, mm-hmm, I have to generate at least $500,000 in incremental revenue as a result of them being in this position or whatever. You can kind of reverse engineer it and then you find that the bar is way higher. It's like, oh, okay. Yeah. If this is what it's gonna require for this person to pay for themselves, do I really believe they can drive a half million dollars of extra sales? Yeah. And sometimes they can, but often you're like, no, you know what? Something about the operations of the business has convinced me we need a position that I can't actually justify paying for itself.
Yeah, you're, you're, I think there's like this thing where, uh, it's like return on invested capital for consumer brands is like, if I put a dollar into ads, I'm probably going to get back like 3 or 4 bucks over some period of time.
Yeah.
Right. So every dollar I don't put into ads needs to generate at least something like that or needs to enable me to spend that.
I mean, to put it really simply, what you just said, We should hold our overhead expenses to the same standard we hold our marketing expenses to.
100%. Totally.
We are doing attribution, we are doing incrementality, we are looking at ROAS because it would be insane to not look at those things. But with overhead, it's this whole chunk of costs in your business that can totally fly under the radar where we're never really trying to figure out, hey, how is that driving the business forward?
And I think the one thing we learned is actually how to drive revenue. Because when we had so much overnight success, things were just working. Yeah. And so we started adding on fixed costs to get more revenue.
Yeah.
When in reality is we just needed to spend more on meta and keep the OpEx low. Like in 20— in 2022, if we ran the business now, it would've been like tens of millions of dollars we would've had in profit. Like it was absurd, but we weren't that good on meta. Like we didn't, we weren't that good of operators on understanding that line of business. And so we just, we would add, we had a huge influencer marketing team, we had a huge product team. We hired someone from Nike and they didn't know the customer and they were ordering products in the wrong way without focusing on replenishment. So we would drop a bunch of products that had one-time usage but didn't have great LTV. So the, I mean, I was telling my dad this the other day, the tariffs just taught us how to run the business. Like every, we were molded into great e-com operators because Because we were forced to look at the depths of our business that we didn't have the opportunity to before because growth almost, uh, like hid a lot of our problems.
Yeah.
So it was, it was a, it was a huge blessing. Like, I feel like dangerous moving forward.
I, I have always felt like in your very best days, the seeds of your downfall are being sown. And in your very worst days, the seeds of your future growth and overcoming are being sown. And I think that's exactly what you're saying when things are going awesome. So one of the ways I tell it with our business, We had a couple years in '23, '24, EBITDA margins are mid-20s.
Wow.
We're talking close to 9 figures in EBITDA in those 2 years. And for sure, the worst decisions we made in the business and some of the most lax, most abdicating leadership I gave happened during that period. But it's easy to see why. I mean, we were just crushing it. It seemed like everything was so easy. 25, man, it's just the opposite, right? It's like an absolute slugfest. Yeah. It feels like I overnight have become terrible at running a business. But this year I think we're already starting to see some of the fruit of that and how we've like, we're on a much better trajectory. So Stephen, I wanna go back before we talk more about the last year and a half. How did you start the company?
[Sponsor Content] Matt Bertulli: All right. Traffic is expensive. Wasting it even more expensive. Brands spend so much money getting people to their site, but they often overlook how much value they could be getting from the traffic they already have. Most popups still treat every visitor the same and give brands a limited opportunity to capture and convert that traffic. This is why we have Alia sponsoring the show, guys. Alia turns your popup into a revenue engine. It helps brands capture more subscribers, personalize the onsite experience, and continuously optimize for the business outcomes that matter most— profit. Alia uses things like smart triggering, Prism AI, and smart testing to determine when to show a popup, and which experiences perform best in different contexts. And continuously you should be improving performance here. There are like 5,000 brands that trust Alia, like Nike and Peloton and Groon's, Pela. Huge fans. We are, we love Alia. Brands commonly see 2 to 3 times more signups within 30 days and up to 5x ROI within 90 days. If you want to book a demo, they're offering an extended 45-day free trial for the operators community. When you book, just mention that we sent you.
Yeah, so I started the company, I was working at an advertising agency. I was 24. My boss kicked me out of a meeting and he said, that t-shirt's not professional enough for the workforce. I was wearing an active, like, black tee with, like, jeans and a nice shirt. We had Dasani coming in. And then 3 months later, I got laid off. And so on my break, I would walk around and I would go to these stores. I'd be like, I think I could start something. I was running like the lowest level of Facebook ads for Dasani where it was like awareness campaigns. I didn't really know what I was doing, but I was in the Meta sphere at that time. And then at the same time, my buddy had started MVMT Watches and I went to a party and he showed me his Shopify. It said $10K a day. The next time I saw him, it said, it showed like $50K. And I was like, this, this. And he is like, oh, I just do Meta ads. And I was like, oh, okay. I had a really good reference point. I had just got laid off, so I I was like, called my dad. I said, hey, I'm moving home. And I started working for my dad making like $30K a year, but I was working, living at home. And from like 2016 to 2017, I was 26, 27 then. And I just, I call it year zeros in the business where I worked on the business, launched a Kickstarter, and then learned Facebook ads at the same time.
When's your first sale?
It was on shop— on Kickstarter, it was end of 2016, and then it took us about a year to get, get the products. It was August of 2017.
It was the heyday of meta ads.
Yeah.
We had like a— Those were like the best years ever.
$2 CPM.
Yeah, dude. I like, those were some of my best memories.
When the Winks were like $200 CPMs.
Yeah. Oh God.
So you were really scrappy during that, those early days. Like you said, you're living with your parents. What's the scrappiest thing you remember doing in the very, very early days of Cuts to get it stood up?
We obviously, I had saved like $40,000 and then we raised $40,000, but we quickly realized that $80,000 was like a fourth of the PO price we needed. So at the time, like interest rates were low, and so I could get a credit card that was about $50K, zero APR for 12 months. So I did one with one bank and got an— I had, so I got $100K and I was living at home and I was like, I think I was so desperate to move out. Like, no 26, 27-year-old wants to live in Wenatchee, Washington, which is a tiny little town in Washington. With their parents. With their parents. And like, I wanted to move back to LA or New York and like start the business, but I said I wasn't gonna move until we, I think we could do at least $10 million. And so, We pretty much got there like in our first year or year and a half. And we had no full-time employees up until $10 million. We had 4 guys working on it. One guy from college, 2 guys from that I grew up with, and me, and all different skill sets. One finance, one operations, one marketing. I ran the Meta ads at that point. And we were just, we were using credit cards, paying them off, and then the credit cards would get all the way up to $400K. It was like, I, it, it was an incredible time to start a business because of that. Like, I don't think those exist anymore. We never had to pay interest on it because we, uh, just would, we would pay it.
Yeah. There's a—
And you're also racking up rewards, right? You're like—
And that's how I paid myself.
Wow.
I didn't, we, uh, the other guys worked pro bono. Um, and, and I just paid myself with, with credit cards. I mean, I remember it was like $500, then $1,000, and then, You know, it was like 10 grand a month and I was like, all right, this is, this is decent enough to move to LA. I moved to LA on credit card points.
$2 CPMs.
I just, I can't.
Rewards on, on credit card points.
And they got rid of those too. Both of those.
I know. That's all. Those are, those are days.
Those are such good memories, but then they also cause me great grief.
I know.
Like today.
It's like now when we talk about the boomers buying a house for like a, you know, a sack of beans or something and yeah.
Yeah. MetaX was a sack of beans.
So you stand this up as a Kickstarter. It takes about a year for the product to fully come in and for you guys to get rolling. At what point do you feel like it was obvious that you had product market fit?
I think the first Black Friday, like we blew out our, uh, growth goals. I think for us, we did like almost like a million dollars that the, it was really the second year. It was massive. Um, and I was talking to Jake and he was like, keep spending. He, 'cause they, they were like a $50 million business at this time, Jake Kassan. And I was, I, I talked with him. I was like, well, how much do you think we should order for November and December? And he was like, I think you should order enough to do a million bucks, like over that window. But we ended up doing it by the end of Black Friday. I don't know if it was a million bucks on Black Friday or a million bucks that weekend. It was like—
That's amazing. I remember this math. You're talking like 13, 14 months in the business. You had a million dollar day on Black Friday or like
72 hours, something like
that. Yeah.
Yeah. Still incredible.
Yeah.
So, okay, so it's really obvious, like, hey, we've got something here.
And you know what, that same winter, Patrick Mahomes' then-girlfriend Brittany bought, and we saw him post it. And we're in, like, all of our, like, early fans were like, oh, I think this is, this is him. And then he did his, like, Christmas family photos, and it was like, clearly the X is showing. And we were like, Let's go. He had just kind of—it was right when it was like 2018 or 2019 when he was just kind of coming up from.
He was getting big.
Yeah. Yeah.
When did you come up with the sport of business line?
That was journey. Yeah. It was kind of early on. We were like, we need a tagline for the sport of business, and our first tagline was actually: If you go to who gon stop me dot com, who gon no e. That was like our first tagline. It was like it's four of us who
gon stop me.
Yeah, and it's actually a redirect. If you go to who gon stop me dot com, it redirects to cut. Still,
I love that.
We got that from Amazon. If you go to relentless.com, it actually goes to Amazon.
He bought that way back in the day. He wanted to name it, didn't he want, he wanted to name Amazon Relentless and people were like, this is a very bad idea, Jeff. Do not do this. Uh, and so you're still living with mom and dad?
I'm still living with mom and dad
today. Okay. A lot's happened. I guess we need to catch up. So, uh, at what point were you like, okay, I am now trying to start paying these other guys that have been working on this with me. I'm gonna start to try and stand this up into like a legitimate company.
So right about that time, I think it was early 2018, I was like, all right, I'm gonna move to LA. And I remember thinking, I don't know if I can afford like paying myself with credit card points, like $60,000. I was like, that's how much it's gonna cost to live in LA. Uh, I moved there first and then our second employee, Sean, uh, moved from Washington right about that time. And we were, it was, it was a big decision. I was like, I don't, I, uh, I'm not sure if we can even afford the two of us at the time. We paid him like $30,000 a year, um, back then.
Crazy.
In LA.
And well, he moved— Los Angeles.
He moved in with his, uh, new wife's, uh, grandparents.
Wow.
In like Thousand Oaks. And he would have to commute into Culver City. Like, you know, it was, he figured out, you know?
Yeah.
Um, but this is what it is, man. It's not glamorous.
It wasn't glamorous.
You know, like it's so glamorous when you're scaled up, but like, We talk about all the time how consumer is like the overnight success story that took 10 or 15 years to build. And I guarantee you year 1 and year 2 are like not glamorous at all.
Yeah. I mean, it was every day we were looking at our, like one understanding if we had cash. And then what was kind of a big moment for us was one of my college friends' dad was like the Jack in the Box CFO. He was like a CFO for Jack in the Box. And I went to school with him and he was a San Diego State guy. And I was at lunch with him one day and I was like, yeah, like no bank wants to give us a loan. I'm on these credit cards that are pretty crazy. And he was like, hey, I'll give you $500K as a loan. And 'cause his other business was doing loans for college loans. And he is like, I could give you one. Little did I know it was like 12% back then, which was a lot. Yeah, yeah. But We, we were like, yeah, we'll take it. And he was like, can you pay me back in 4 months? I was like, yeah, we can pay you back in, in 4 months. And so that was actually a pretty big moment to get $500,000 plus. So we had now like working capital of like $750K and we were turning inventory so fast.
Did at some point, I gotta ask, man, like t-shirts, clothing is so hard. Like we know that to be true now. At any point did this cross your mind? Like I should not start a clothing business. Like this is a very bad category.
Uh, pretty much every day, still to this day. Uh, so So not to skip ahead, but I think clothing, if you don't know what you're doing, can be a very inefficient business.
Yeah.
Because there's inventory risk. Like going back to the profitability, what we were talking about earlier is you need to know, okay, what is your contribution on the month? Simply put, if it's using simple math, let's say your business can generate $500K of contribution margin, but your fixed costs are $600K and then your interest expense is $50K, you're going to lose $150K. Yeah. So you just— that's like the most basic understanding. But that's only one part of the equation. The other part is how much inventory did you order?
Yep. Yeah.
And how much of that inventory is on terms or how much is, uh, is owed? So if you, let's say you crush the contribution margin, you have plenty of contribution margin, but from a cash flow perspective, you've ordered too much. That's another way the business goes out.
Yeah. There's a lot of ways you can die with things that happen.
In apparel. Yeah. You're speaking specifically to— Yeah.
When you have high inventory risk, there's just a lot of ways that you can die, like where you, You go bankrupt with a business that on paper makes money, but you've got 8 billion extra, extra large shirts in olive in your warehouse that, you know, have taken you under. And so like, when did you start to understand the challenges that were gonna come with this business?
I think so through one of the genius things we did, but we didn't know it was genius. We weren't apparel guys. We had no, I didn't know what a pattern maker was when I started the business. Like, I know nothing. And, uh, we had one fabric through 40 million and, uh, we only used one fabric. So the typical risk of an apparel company, we didn't experience.
You weren't even smart enough to do the stupid thing.
We, exactly. Yeah. So we had, we had shop-by-cut. So we had one tee, 3 different cuts, split hem, elongated, and straight, 3 collars, V-neck, crew, and Henley, short and long sleeve. And, and then we would just replenish product. But what that did was, and I think you guys have said it on your podcast where it's 80% easier to get a second order just from the same product they acquired, just a different color, than a completely new product. So we were doing that. Like, hey, you got a crew shirt, maybe you get a V-neck or a Henley. And then because the product was so sticky, and then at the same time we were seeding all these athletes, that one product had high concentration in the marketplace. And then we almost created the dress workup t-shirt. We created that market. Um, before it really existed. And we were, we were everywhere and we had such good, uh, operating rhythm of, of restocks and replenishment that our LTV was just like some of the best LTV numbers, uh, you've ever seen.
Like, give us a frame of reference. What, what kind of LTVs were you looking at?
Within, uh, during that period, uh, if you acquired like our Crew Curve shirt, uh, we were pro— we were, uh, 60% of the cohort came back within 3 months. Wow.
So you're getting—
That's really solid.
You're getting really solid 3-digit—
And then within a year, uh, from a revenue standpoint, not from a customer standpoint, we had more, we had exceeded the, the—
Initial purchase.
The initial purchase.
Man, that's amazing.
Because we had, we would have the lower, lower cohort would order 10, 11, 12. Yeah. So the net revenue retention was really high.
[Sponsor Content] Simple Modern works with Walmart every day, and I can tell you from our meetings that the walmart.com marketplace is a huge area of focus in their business. When the biggest retailer in the world says that something's important to them, you can be sure they're going to make the investment to do it with excellence. The holidays start early on the Walmart marketplace. Apply to sell and get your inventory to Walmart Fulfillment Services to prepare for millions of holiday shoppers. Build your seasonal assortment with customer favorites, products that Walmart customers love and are actively searching for. Add eligible customer favorites to your catalog and you could receive up to 100% off referral fees for those items. What an amazing offer. Get ready to crush the holidays by signing up for the Walmart Marketplace. Visit marketplace.walmart.com/operators and sign up today.
Oh, that is so good, man. And so rare. Apparel is like within 12 months, you usually see like a 30 or 50%. Like if you make a dollar, you get like a buck 50.
Yeah.
Right. So you guys were way, way past that. Oh, that is amazing.
And, and, and, but we didn't know that. We weren't smart enough to know that's what was driving the success.
Yeah.
Because so then coming out of that, we started adding all these collections. We're like, we need to do some cool drops. Like all these cool companies like Kith do cool drops. So we started doing these drops that did really well, they'd be huge revenue boost, but it would, it would, we would say, no, instead of 10 colors on the PDP, we're gonna do 3. So then the LTV started to go down because they didn't have those products they wanted to, that wanted to buy. And then we had more inventory risk with those drops at extra larges we had too many of. And then that's what slowly, uh, inventory risk started to creep.
It's just eating away at your cash. And cash is really precious at that point anyway. You already mentioned the credit cards. You mentioned, people don't understand, like the hardest part about growing a business that has inventory is working capital.
Yeah.
I think you're doing a good job of verbalizing that, and that's why it's so intensely painful when you have inventory sitting there doing nothing, because that's cash that you know how to deploy other places, but you just can't get to it.
Mm-hmm.
Did you get to a point during that initial growth period where you started to realize you had an inventory problem?
No, then we never really had an inventory problem. It was during the initial growth. With those, uh, with the Pika Pro fabric, it really came, uh, kind of in '22 when we started doing that drop prom, when all of a sudden you would see $30K here, $40K here, you know, and it just, it started to add. And, uh, one of the things we learned how to deal with that is when you look at your annual budget, how much can you liquidate for your cost back? Like, and there's like a couple different channels, you know, you go to TJ Maxx.
You do that annually?
We do it annually.
Okay.
So when we look at our an— and it's not perfect. Nothing's perfect.
No, no, nothing's perfect. Yeah. Yeah.
But it's like, let's say we're gonna, we're gonna place $10 million to use round numbers. We know we can liquidate around $1.5 to $2 on a year profitably.
Okay.
So our inventory, like risk, if we're gonna do drops, need, needs to be less than $2 million because we know if those products don't hit, we can li— we can liquidate 'em. And then the replenishment stuff we have, we're less concerned about it 'cause we've been selling them for years. So if we need to slow down purchases of those inventory, we can just slow down and, and, and, and not purchase it in subsequent months.
And I'm jumping ahead here, but one of the things that happened in '25 and during these periods where everybody's heavy, everybody's heavy at the same time.
Oh yeah.
And so you think I can sell this much in liquidation channels, but you can only sell 50% of that because they're sitting there being like, yeah, you know what? I think, uh, I'm gonna offer you this really lowball offer and if you don't take it, I've got a line. Yeah, exactly. All right, Stephen, walk me through the revenue ramp year by year.
So it was in, it was $2 mil 2017, 2018 was $10, 2019 was, uh, $22, '21 was, uh, $44, and then $62 in, uh, '22.
Wow. So like amazing growth. Sounds like the COVID era was a huge accelerant to the business. Tell us about that period and how it hit the business.
So it, I think most of our problems were, uh, research, uh, building up when, if you remember when the shipping crisis happened.
Mm-hmm.
Because, uh, we, we lost gross margin. We, and we didn't, we didn't know it. We're like, oh yeah, air stuff, things are going so well. We had one fabric in '21 and then we had, we were like, we sold 50,000 pairs of joggers, uh, with sight unseen. We had never even seen a sample. We just ordered 50,000.
Oh.
But, but it worked and our, and, and at the end of '21, heartburn. We didn't, we just didn't know what we were doing. It was, it was, uh, I look back and it actually, even talking about it gives me, uh, goosebumps. But, uh, we had, we had got one sample. It was like $50,000 and then we sold 'em by the end of the year. But that was the worst thing that could have happened to us because then it gave us like un— like confidence that we shouldn't have had.
Yeah, I could do this every year.
And I,
that is so true. Yeah. I wanna stop there for a second. Like they say this about, um, people that manage money and stock picking, the worst thing that can possibly happen is that you buy a stock with a poor thesis or with poor research. Yeah. And then it doubles or triples or whatever, 'cause you're like, this thing's easy.
I'm a fricking genius.
And that's what you're saying is that you guys did something you shouldn't have done.
Yeah.
But it worked. And that was the worst thing that could have ever happened to you.
Yeah, it was. 'Cause we didn't have good methodology around like 2 things why it worked. And then I'll say why the fu— the 3rd product wouldn't work. We had one product for 4 years, more or less. That was just one fabric. What pairs perfectly with a t-shirt is a jogger. So all of those big cohorts of customers that we had acquired are gonna buy that jogger, but that 3rd and 4th and 5th, it gets a little worse every time. And so, I mean, we, uh, it just, it, it's, there's a huge drop-off from your like top 5 to even your 6th. You guys see that?
Yes. Yeah,
it's difficult. We talked about this recently in another episode that You assume that, hey, because I've sold you a shirt and you love the shirt, of course you're gonna want the jogger. Of course you're gonna want, you know, the pullover or whatever. And it's actually, you're solving a different problem with those products and you do have to resell the customers. I mean, you do have some brand equity, but it's not as one-to-one as you would like to think as a brand owner.
Yeah. I mean, we, and I think Zach Stuck talks about this recently, is like, what's the most important thing for an e-com business is funnel congruency. I'm stealing his word.
Yeah, it's so freaking important.
So if people have not heard funnel congruency before, how would you describe the concept?
So if someone's coming to like a, our everyday selection of our brand, that page needs to be for that everyday consumer. So a t-shirt and a jogger versus we have everyday clothing, which is polos, t-shirts, and joggers, more or less. Those are things that are high replenishment, that we, that the ads, they start with ads. Do the ads have those products? Do the landing pages show those products? And is it, is it curated for that type of consumer?
That lifestyle.
That lifestyle. Are the images on the PDP that way? Then we also have an elevated, which is doing really well for us right now, which is a little bit more dress-uppy. But now if we had kind of our joggers on that and you can't pair it together, because like from an AOV perspective in apparel, we love, we want our, uh, our UPT to increase, units per transaction. And if you don't have funnel—
Why do you want it to increase?
Because if we can, let's say our, our CAC is, you know, $60 and someone's going to purchase 1 item or 1 or 1.5 on average, it's going to be hard to be profitable. But if we can get UPT up to 3, And AOV goes up, then that same CAC can be more contribution margin dollars.
And the margins get proportionally better with every additional unit.
Yeah.
Because a lot of the shipping cost doesn't scale proportionally. Totally makes sense. Okay, so keep going. So you've got this funnel congruency where you're trying to, whatever somebody kind of like, whatever the hook that they came in on, you're wanting to make sure that you're showing them that stuff all the way through the purchasing journey, right?
And then on lower funnel as well, email.
Funnel congruency. So you're really focusing on funnel congruency, especially it sounds like as you're introducing some very different lanes, like if you're really trying to have more of a professional dress-up angle, don't show that person the jogger. They're not looking for a jogger. Nobody's wearing joggers to the office.
Exactly. And that's one of the big things we learned out of COVID um, or out of, uh, the tariffs is like those funnels need to be tight and the customer journey's got to be super tight. And
how do you keep it tight?
It all, it starts from the ideation and that's where the CEO really has to live is he has to go from the very, very beginning ideation to, uh, the purchase event.
Yeah. It's a zoom in, zoom out thing. You gotta be really good at it.
And, and, and listen to this pod. You, uh, I, I've, I've learned so much. I mean, there's no place for game in e-commerce than here, you know, uh, a shout out. But I've learned a lot from Sean. I play tennis with him every Wednesday, talking to Zach too. He, he's, he's great in this. And, uh, just consistency in the messaging is so important because customers are, they're not, you have to realize they're not in the boardroom with you every day. They're just not. Um, and, and then if you, that's funnel congruency with a long-term buying approach in apparel. So like I mentioned before, the funnel congruency of like an AOT needs high replenishment every month because how, how do you stop the growth of your business in, in, in, in our line is let's say you have funnel congruency, but then you don't replenish those products that they bought, your LTV is gonna shrink in, in those product—
So you're saying, if I could put words to it, you're saying it's hard for us to be first order profitable, but we're bringing people through these very specific persona funnels and saying, hey, we can be your casual wear provider. And, you know, Cuts is the brand for you where not just I convert them on that particular journey, but that they're coming back because these are items that they're gonna buy a lot of, like a t-shirt, that they're coming back month after month after month. And that's how the whole economic flywheel works, is that I'm selling them on buying t-shirts from Cuts. But then if I'm not there delivering that month after month after month, the whole thing breaks down.
Yep. And then when, and it ruins like momentum in the business. So like you can have, you can do funnel congruence, congruency, right? And just a really tight funnel. But then if, if those replenishments aren't coming in, all of a sudden your meta spend 'Cause we break our Meta account up by, uh, like funnel as well. So it'll be like the edit
category first and then funnel
category first.
So it's like category and then for people listening and watching, then it's like message.
Yes.
So like I could take the same shirt and I could have like 5 different messages and 5 different personas to buy the exact same product is how you guys think about it?
Uh, yes. And so, and that's how we think about it from, uh, just a business planning.
Yep.
Everything. And then with Claude, it's so amazing. You can have dashboards by funnel. I mean, never a better time to understand where you're at as a CEO. That's why I think Claude is really good for CEOs because you can design it exactly the way you need to see it.
Yep.
Um, that's a little tangent, but—
No, it totally is. And I think one of the things that the, the AI tools have made it possible is like there used to be metrics that it's like, well, this takes a whole bunch of, uh, work to kind of pull all the numbers together. And so I can look at it maybe every 2 or 3 weeks. And now it's like, no, no, no, I have it on demand whenever I want it. And It just really changes how effectively you're able to manage.
And you can talk to it like, is this a problem? Are you worried about this? Like, what should we do?
I do that all the time, actually. I engage with it via voice mode, and then I will just ask it qualitative questions where, you know, like, okay, how are my funnels looking? Where should I be paying attention? What's the, where's our leakiest funnel? Why do you think it's leaking? And it's amazing how effective it is at pointing me in the right direction. There's still, you know, like human judgment is Uh, is ultimately necessary to run a really effective business. But so much of our job is trying to figure out where to put our attention. There's a million things going on, like where in the business actually requires my thought.
It's quality of questions, right? Like, yeah, that's what you guys are both hitting on. It's like your, your job as a great CEO, especially in consumers, like you just get very good at asking the right question at the right time.
[Sponsor Content] Sponsored: [Sponsor Content] Here's the thing most operators haven't caught onto yet. Post-purchase logistics like where's my order, tracking, and returns. It's not overhead. Doing it right isn't just cost savings, it's money hiding in plain sight. Brands like Dr. Squatch, Gymshark, and Mejuri trust AfterShip for smarter tracking, exchange-first or buyer-funded returns, and tracking page upsells. Talk to AfterShip, mention Titans, and get 15% off 1 year of Enterprise plan For first-time customers. If you're serious about delighting your customers with the one thing you'll ever send with 100% open rate, their order, use the link in the description, aftership.com, and tell them the operator sent you.
Yeah, it's funny that we think our job is providing answers, but a lot of times our job is actually asking, are we asking the right question? Okay, so you have, uh, kind of started to figure out funnels. The company has grown really rapidly, but as you have grown, there are kind of cracks in retrospect that are kind of forming. There's some behaviors in buying that are not disciplined, but worked out. You dodged the bullet, but, but it reinforced the behavior. And there's some inventory kind of sloppiness that's starting to accumulate. Mm-hmm. And this is going on as you're growing. You're in '22, you're at 60, how much?
62.
You're at $62 million. So now walk me through what happens in '23, '24.
So '23, '24, and '25. So '23, we actually had a good year, similar revenue, like 20% growth. And then, but we had real, we, we stopped trying to acquire customers. We just, uh, so we were acquiring much less as a percentage.
Why did you stop? Did the CPAs take off on you?
Uh, we, I think there was a bunch of things that happened. One, I think there was more competition that we wanted, that we, that was at a lower price that we didn't, we were like, we're cuts. Like, they're gonna buy our price no matter what. There's more competition in the marketplace.
Do you think that was hubris in retrospect?
Uh, that was ego.
Yeah.
Yeah, it was ego.
This is, this is the number one thing. And I think this is why I said earlier that like when, you know, on your best days, the seeds of destruction are being sown. Like, no matter how many times you hear it, you get cocky.
Mm-hmm.
You get arrogant, you get hubris.
Totally.
And you just think, I'm bulletproof. Sounds like you guys wrestled with that.
Yeah. I mean, uh, I think like, yeah, the, sometimes in, in, in business you just gotta get checked, you know, as this, as this, like, it's that simple. Uh, I, I see younger guys on talking, flaunting, uh, uh, revenue and, uh, they, uh, like on, on Twitter and stuff and they're, and they're saying, we're just gonna buy if we We, we could go outta business and stuff like that if, if the buys go bad. And I'm like, I've, we've seen those, we've seen those stories. You know, when peak of our growth, we had talked to this investment group and they were between us and Parade, if you remember.
Oh yeah.
And Parade was like, their thesis was all sizes for everybody. And I go to them, I was like, what
could go wrong?
What could
go wrong?
And they said, hey, we're gonna give $20 million. They gave, it was like 20 and 20, 20 out, 20 in. The business doesn't exist 18 months later.
Yeah.
Because they got the money to invest on all these products that they couldn't sell. Um, and so I think that would've happened to us. It's like the best things in, in life sometimes don't happen.
Mm-hmm.
Because I think in that moment we wouldn't have known what, what to do.
It would've been the most dangerous time in your business to take capital.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah.
Well, sure. It would've compounded the,
the
problem, the bad behavior. That's right.
It, it would've been like handing matches to a kid. Yeah. You know, it's like that. Sometimes, like you said, the things, the opportunities that we don't get, they're actually beneficial. So as you're going through this period, like you said, '23 is a pretty good growth year. What is the point where you really started to realize we've got a problem?
It really started with, so the end of '23, I think we moved, we were able to get like a, this line of credit, this bank doesn't exist anymore. I was actually an investor in this bank. It was like an online e-commerce like lender. We, they, in one, like a 3-hour window, they, they approved us for a $25 million.
What could go wrong?
That is just,
yeah, it doesn't, I actually think it's illegal in the state of New York now to offer these type of loans. Um, and 'cause you actually, they take over your banking, so it's like you look in, it's their banking and—
Oh yeah, that sounds like a great idea, paper.
Yeah, it was terrible. But look at all this cash here. So, uh, long story short, uh, because I was an investor, I got double effed essentially because When problems started to arise, he, I would, he, this, the founder calls me, he's like, hey, can you go to Goldman with me and just talk about your business and why the, the brand's doing so well? And I go and he's like, oh, everything's gonna work out. And then like 2 weeks later, we look in our bank account and we had $5 mil outstanding. And luckily I only took out, I only wanted $10 of the $25.
Right.
Uh, 'cause we didn't need that much.
Some discipline to still like, I don't want all that.
But all of a sudden the 5 was gone that was in our checking, and then it was just siphoning out money. So then if you think from an LTV perspective of not able to order inventory,
sure.
All of a sudden our LTV just started going down and our cats were going up. It was just a death spiral.
So, okay, I wanna understand. You, you took on this money and then they get distressed, so they claw back some of the money. Is that what happened?
So they, they just Because they had access to your banking and your Shopify payments.
Uh, they, they just ran a sweep on
you. They took the, the money that was left in their account. Boom. It's gone. 'Cause it was like a run on the bank, essentially.
A lot of times this happens when you're financing, uh, receivables or whatever.
Yeah.
Depending on how you're, you're situated is that they actually have the same access to your, they can run a sweep on you.
Depending on the lender, right? This is why you should almost always only borrow from a large bank.
They don't do that.
Well, if you can. Yeah. But you know, you say that, but it's like, if you can, there's a lot of small brands that can't.
Yeah. Yeah.
But like, I think what you're saying here, you know, you wanna talk about another use of AI. There was so much information asymmetry when you were taking on debt or equity financing in the past. Like these people do it professionally and, you know, you get these packets that have—
40 pages.
40 pages. Yeah. And they're just like, sign here, here, and here. And you just don't read 'em. And if you do read 'em, you don't understand 'em. And this is one of those things where it's like, just don't sign anything that you don't run through a model and say, what am I signing? What am I agreeing to? Hey, what are the trade-offs? What are the downsides?
Mm-hmm.
You didn't know about any of this stuff when you signed it.
I recently did that with the agreement from this company and it like, my physical body like got scared.
Here's the 10 ways I'm gonna get screwed from this.
Yeah. Yeah.
But you're like, well, of course I'm gonna get screwed in this agreement. But at the time you weren't thinking that way.
And everything was going good. Like that year we had grown, but the, it was like, it was like we were relying on these massive cohorts and then we took it and then competition came in. Also more discounting became a thing on e-commerce.
Yep.
And, uh, I think Sean's great. Like you kind of, the way Sean Ridge business grows is he's grown horizontally.
Yeah.
It's not always with depth. And we needed to find our next AO jogger. And we, we kind of were, uh, we weren't innovating enough to get those growth levels, but we were spending like we wanted to. So CAC started to creep. AOVs actually were kind of dipping because we didn't have, uh, and just, it was like all these little micro problems. Like we weren't understanding our place in the marketplace very well. I don't think I was doing a good job just talking to other founders, understanding what's going on. Everything's changing so fast. And it was just like 10 different things looking back where we're kind of making our business harder to operate.
And you're starting to feel the heat turn up end of '24, mid-'24?
Yeah. Uh, the bank failure happened, I think, the early part of '24. And then the, the hard part of that was it, we had to refinance then as the business wasn't doing well anymore. And, uh, um, it, it was just a very, a very difficult time. So, and then, and then we didn't know our business well enough, so we didn't know where to cut and stuff.
Yeah, sure.
It's like we had signed up for NetSuite and all these things that were like hundreds of thousands of dollars. Um, and it just added to that contribution margin lift. Um, and so that, that was really hard. That took us from like February to September of '24. Then we actually had a pretty good Q4. And then I'm like, all right, we can, we can have a comeback.
So how are you feeling coming outta '24 at this point going into '25?
I'm thinking, okay, we had a really difficult year, but next year let's just like try to get back to where we were the year before.
Mm-hmm.
You know, a little bit of decrease, but we'll be fine. Like it's a little blimp and, you know, we, we were bootstrapped, like we're still bootstrapped at this point. Never had raised a dollar. I was like, this might be a good time to try that, maybe get a, a bad valuation, but I still own most of, almost all the, the company. This is why I held onto that much equity, you know? But little did I know, like in that situation, like the apparel market went to zero.
Okay. 2025, what actually happened?
So we're, we're coming out, we had finished, we had fixed the kind of a working capital issue at the time. We have a really good product plan going in, and then We grew like 15 to 25% in Q1, and at the end of Q1, it was like end of March, uh, tariffs get announced. And if you remember, they were as high as 145%. And our business was uniquely affected by it because of the way the tariffs were imposed and the way our business operated. Our business was bringing in goods, like a lot of apparel companies, from Tijuana And on an order basis, you would pay tariffs. And so we were circumventing the tariffs through a legal means with—
The previous tariffs.
The previous tariffs.
And so just so everybody understands this, you would bring the goods from Tijuana to where?
Into San Diego, then they would ship to the customer.
Okay, but you wouldn't actually pay the tariffs on like a shirt until it was shipped to the customer.
Was this a 301?
You would know before. The previous tariffs, you would avoid the tariff completely.
And you were avoiding it. Explain to people how this worked. How'd the mechanism work earlier that you were avoiding and why did that end up biting you now?
So I think it was in 2013, President— I think in 2013, the law got changed where if the MSRP was $800 or lower and it was a single parcel of single unit, you wouldn't pay tariffs. So what happened was, All the big e-com companies, especially apparel, I mean, name a company, they use this, were over in Tijuana. And when a customer would purchase, those packages would get bulked up and shipped over the border one by one. And, uh, that, and you would avoid paying tariffs completely.
So you were shipping orders basically individually from Tijuana to the United States to avoid tariffs, which were not insignificant to start.
Millions and millions of dollars.
But for people listening, this is like literally part of the North America Free Trade Agreement.
Yeah.
Like this was law for a long time.
Well, this was common practice.
It was very common. And
this is a machine and, uh, you know, all of the, the Chinese, uh, e-commerce sites were taking advantage of this. This was, you know, like this was not limited to a particular group of people.
There's almost in apparel, if you, it would be more common to see someone not doing it than, than doing it. That's how everyone was doing it.
Yeah, for sure.
So in 2025, we walk into an environment where there's now tariffs. Why do those tariffs now impact you the way the previous ones didn't?
So I think the normal tariff that we were circumventing was like 32% on our goods. So then not only did they, we have to pay the 32%, we, they got increased to as high as 145 and 155, and then it kind of bounced around. Um,
because they removed this exception for small parcels.
Yes. Yeah. But then the, so imagine this. So they get announced, I think it was, uh, either April 1st or May 1st. Uh, we, so a lot of businesses that brought their stuff into the US, they had some, they had some, uh, runway of non-tariffed, high-tariffed items. For us, it was, they were sitting over the border and every order in order to get, get the customer their good had to pay those tariffs when they got up to 145, 155. I mean, they were bouncing around. So in one week, the first week of tariffs, we had a $600K Uh, bill. I mean, it was crazy because—
$600K the first week?
Because it was, we had, we paid—
That's insane.
The, the $155K I think lasted, or $145K, like a few weeks. Yeah.
So you literally did not wanna sell things on your site.
We didn't know what to do.
Yeah. You're totally trapped. You've got all this inventory in Tijuana.
No, zero inventory in the US.
Zero in the US, but it's all in Tijuana and you're like, okay, what do we do with all this? 'Cause we can't sustain $600,000 in tariffs a week, and there's no way to kind of push this off or delay this.
It was like an impossible situation. So we did slow down advertising, and that's when we just went down to, that's when we went down to 6 employees, essentially. We called it the year of the cockroach, and I go to my guys that I started the business with, more or less, that have been with me, and they're the ones that said 1 person for a department. That didn't include agencies, that 6, or like contract workers or like VAs. I was like, like internal US people. I remember it was like a rocky moment. We sit on the board and we say, hey guys, like, uh, we've come, we've come this far. We have a great brand. People love the business. The cost structure just doesn't make sense right now. I'm not sure how we're gonna do it, but I know the best thing to do is just start cutting costs everywhere and like extend our runway. And it was a, you know, for that month where it was really high, that was like existential. And And we quick— and at the same time, we were gonna try to raise a little bit of money. So we had to, the first thing I did was I just brought everyone in the room that wasn't gonna be there and explained to them the issue. And then I, at the same time, wrote a letter to the sitting president at the time, and I just said, hey, I voted for you, but I disagree with the policy, and here's why. And I was very respectful. It wasn't, you know, name-calling. It was like, here, here, this is how it's gonna hurt small business of America. Uh, that ended up going, uh, viral. I was on This Week in Startups, CNN, Fox News, Financial Times. I was
like, it was like everywhere for like a 2-week period. I'm like, Borrelli's haunting me. Yeah.
And, uh, but the, the cool thing about that is, so the first thing we did, and I think people listening, I know there's a lot of businesses that things aren't going well and your cost structure doesn't make sense. The first thing I would do is just cut, burn even more than you think you need to. So we renegotiated with all our agency suppliers, uh, with our pending POs, we just cut 'em. And if we just said, hey, we may not be around, so either you like it or sue us, essentially. Um, and we just tried to get out of any cost we could, uh, to extend our runway. So less cash is going out the door on the daily. on the daily basis. That's the first thing I would do. Uh, then we, we knew we, we need, we needed to raise a little bit of money. So when I went on this press tour, what it did was in previous years, this is the beautiful thing about how God works sometimes. We had tried to raise in past years, but it just didn't, didn't happen for us. When people saw this article, it was like, oh, I love Cuts. This brand doesn't deserve to get hit. Now I had like, you know, 3 investors that were like, oh, I'm behind you. But I, so I raised 4 like in a, in a day, like no diligence. Uh, just people that like just trusted us. Um, you know, that we saw, saw our numbers, but not like a typical process. What I mean, there was diligence, but not, not like—
Not, not your usual like 3-month, you know, 4-month. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
And, uh, uh, but it was contingent on raising this last 3. Mm-hmm. So then when I went on Jake Tapper CNN, This guy DMs me.
This is like an anonymous DM?
An anonymous DM in that other filter at Instagram. Right.
The spam, basically the spam part. Yeah. The spam.
And I had, I had so much spam because I was on, I had, if you go on Reddit, there's like a 20,000 Reddit thread of people like talking shit about me.
No kidding.
Oh man.
The trolls were out during that period because I wrote a very respectful post also that went semi-viral and I got more in that one thread. I got more nasty comments than in the entirety of my entire social media history. Wow.
Same.
Outside of that.
And so I was trying to cycle through those. There was a lot of supportive business founders, like, thanks for speaking up, representing small businesses. But there was a lot of just trolls. And the, the post on Twitter got 2.5 million views, and a lot of my interviews were getting hundreds of thousands of views. Um, so I happened to see it, which was actually like a pretty big thing to actually be able to see it with how many Like it could have easily not happened. So then I go and we're there and, uh, I walk in, I'm like, okay, this could actually be a thing, but I think he thinks it's debt. I think it's debt. 'Cause he said, he used the word credit. He's a, he's a Chinese guy. And, uh, we were talking there and, and so I leave that meeting kind of bummed about it. And then 2 weeks later he's like, hey, hey, are you guys, we would love to work with you. And I was like, no, I'm not, I'm not interested in, in And, uh, debt. And he meant, no, I mean credit. I wanna make your, your, your good, not in the terms of, he was gonna give me production credits for $3.5 million. But at the time we, we left our current supplier, we were in the need of a new supplier. So it was actually like real cash.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And so I had, I called the other investors as I'm like, hey, I got this done. And so then the, the, all, all of the $6 or $7 million came in and we got an incredible valuation at the time. Really? Like these guys, for their credit, they were like, we're not gonna—
Who priced it?
Uh, it was the 2, the 2 main investors.
Okay.
Yeah. They were like, we're, we're gonna give you a really handsome, uh, valuation for, for that time because we believe in this business and we don't wanna like bend you over backwards.
Cool.
Um,
damn dude. Good for you.
Yeah, it was a few, it was single digits of the company.
Sometimes things happen for you. Yeah.
And it was, it was great. Those guys are like my, my guy. I really wanna, I, I know I'm gonna come through for But, uh, we end up getting this great valuation, we get it done, and, uh, that was probably in the summer months.
So you've secured over $7 million in funding.
Yep.
To stabilize the ship. What did you have to do?
So then at that moment, we still had a lot of excess inventory that had crazy high tariffs. So the reason why those selling those daily was very difficult, cuz we lost 20% of gross margin on them.
Yeah.
And, uh, using basic math, like if a t-shirt was, you know, $10 to buy, it was gonna be close to $20 or $15 depending on the unit, which just destroyed your—
It's insane. Yeah.
It was, it was brutal. So what we did was we increased our inventory on good units without the high tariffs because we were, we renegotiated the tariff cost into the cost of good that we're buying. So what we said was we were gonna, sell them both at the same time. So then we had some, we had some—
To blend it out.
To blend it out.
So you were trying to bring over that inventory, kind of mixing it in with new inventory that you had sourced at a new factory. What were the difficulties you ran into as you were getting new production spun up?
Well, what we did, it was almost unthinkable. We had to, our entire catalog, we had to refit. And then like when you make that shirt, There's a lot that goes into making a shirt. You have to get the fit right. And God forbid we're 1 inch off with our customers. Like they come to us because it's a well-fitting shirt.
Well, they're rebuying from you because they're rebuying the fit. If the fit was different every time, you know, that'll crush LTV.
It would. So we had to re— so it actually was a blessing though, because we said, all right, we're only going to do our top like silhouettes. And so it made us really think about what is your top silhouettes? Everything else, we're just, we're just cutting. So we went through our LTV, Uh, you know, we looked at all of our products with the highest LTV and made those first. Uh, so we remade those. And in Q4, we said, we're just going to pretty much rebuy core products. But the problems didn't stop there. September rolls around. We might, we, our cash position was better, but then one of our containers, there's like fell in the ocean, like with all of these new units that we needed.
It really fell in the ocean?
This is like the part of Dumb and Dumber where they talk about their pets' heads falling off. Like, this is just everything going wrong.
And I go, I go to, uh, Sean in our business, like, man, like it was like one of those, it just, it was like a knife in the chest right when we thought we were about to come up, have a huge Q4, better, better, uh, COGS on units, better gross margin. We get, we didn't have products in September and October almost because we had several containers coming in that, and they didn't fall all the way in the water. They were just off the ship. So they got quarantined and they had to get inspected. It was just a nightmare.
How do you not fall all the way in the water?
It was like the, the—
Was it just dragging?
It was like, it was like some of them did.
Like, were you trolling? What happened with the, the container?
It was, it was just a nightmare. Like, uh, and so our insurance was like, no, you're not gonna get full MSRP if you get 'em. Good luck. So we ended up getting 'em late. And, but so what we did though during the summer was we did a customer survey of like, what do you like, guys, buying from Cuts? What we went over price, went over availability. We tried to like do the things that we never had time for in the past of like really understanding the customer. And what we realized was for our basics program, People wanted more deals and bundles. And then on the elevated section, the consumer was moving away from like the Lululemon style and moving more into like dressing up and elevated. So we learned 2 really valuable things, which is leading to our success in '26 that we didn't know before. So we did a lot right in '25 and we were building a really good foundation of a business. We had low burn, we understood our customer better, And we, we're in a better, uh, cash flow perspective to be able to make really good purchase decisions.
It's interesting because in '25 you could not control so much of the world around you.
Mm-hmm.
You can't control tariffs, you can't control the economy, you can't control all containers falling in the ocean. But the one thing that you could control was costs.
Mm-hmm.
And it seems like, and you had some control over fundraising. And so what I hear is that you put a lot of effort in the areas where you actually could impact the outcome, even as you're surrounded by stuff that you were kind of helpless to control.
I was talking to my dad every day. We built such a good relationship. He was just with me and it was right foot, left foot, right foot, left foot. Like today, the mountain is high, but just right foot, left foot, right foot, left foot. I moved to Manhattan Beach and I would just walk on that pier, like right foot, left foot. What am I gonna— what's the most important thing I just need to deal with today? And I'm only gonna focus on that. 'Cause if I stared at the problem, Uh, I, it was gonna feel insurmountable, but today there was something to do. And I, uh, tried to have a good attitude. I wasn't gonna play a victim. I kept thinking like, what a cool story this could be. Like, this is gonna be the story. Every book I read's got a story like this. This is mine. Right foot, left foot, right foot, left foot, right foot, left foot.
Man, I, I tell people all the time, it's like, how do you eat an elephant? One bite at a time.
Mm-hmm.
You just, it has to be. I love that. Right foot, left foot. So as you're going through this, what is the low point?
Mm-hmm. So, uh, right when tariffs hit, uh, something really, uh, devastating happened to me personally too. Uh, that was a, just the hardest thing I've ever gone through. 3 days after that happened, tariffs happened. And, uh, I, uh, I lost like 25 pounds. It was, uh, my, my parents came down. It was like, it was just, it was just one of those moments that like, you just felt like the walls were coming in. Things happened that you just didn't understand and you had no way to get out of it. Um, and, uh, I remember just getting really close with my relationship with the Lord during that time. Um, I would, uh, watch The Chosen. Mm-hmm. I didn't watch anything all year. I would just turn on that at night. Uh, and I would just, I would watch that every single night. I watched the season like 8 times because at night there's my information. I like, I didn't, business podcasts were really not something I wanted to listen to anymore. I didn't find like joy in that. Um, and I just would like listen to like Christian podcasts and just try to be, uh, just grateful for what I had in those, in those moments. And, and, and there's a song that I would listen to over and over. like, I have good plans. I have good plans for you. And it was like this song I just listened to over and over. And I just held onto that because there felt like there was nothing else to hold onto. Like something very close to me left that was like my whole world. And then the business, which was my baby, was in a hard time. And I just would simply just rest in the Lord's promise for my life.
I can totally understand why you wouldn't want to be listening to business podcasts. So often what we hear is just like, oh, here's the story about how I'm awesome and how everything's up and to the right. And yet, like you said, like, that's, that's nobody's real story. Like, that's the really polished version that sometimes we want to put out there because we're trying to perform for other people. But the reality is all of us have these, these periods of intense trial that really test us, shake us to our core, ask us like what we're really about. And it's one of the things that I really appreciate about you sharing your story and even the vulnerability to share that. Like, business isn't our whole world. What's going on in our personal life does matter. And so as you're going through this period, leaning on your faith, right foot, left foot, there's got to be a point where you started to feel like, I think we're done going down and we're starting to go up. Like, things are actually getting better. When did you have that feeling for the first time?
It was like right when we got that PO in that was late, came in, we started doing bundling and then we added innovation at the same time. And then we said, we're going to focus on community. Like I was on every call with our creators and we started kind of running this business new way. And during our decline, our units per transaction was 2.2 with the AOV of like $160, $180. Then when our business started doing better, We decreased our AOV to like $140 with almost, with 3.2 of UPT. Units per transaction. Units per transaction. So when some, from a new customer perspective, they were getting 3.2 items in their cart to try a brand, which versus like bare, like, like in the low 2s. So we just had more value we were giving to the customers, which there was a way bigger bucket of people that wanted to try Cuts at that UPT.
I wanna really stop here because I think this illustrates a point. You listen to people that are in e-commerce and it starts to be like, well, the answer's always get your AOV up, bro. And it's like, no, not necessarily. Like all of this stuff is super contextual. Like what the right AOV for your brand is, is very contextual to what you sell and also your marketing efforts. And what you're saying is that AOV coming down $20 Dropped your customer acquisition cost by $80. It dropped it by 65%. That is such a winning trade. And this is the reason why you can't speak in absolutes. And what works for Simple Modern might not work for Lomi, and that might not work for Cuts. And you're running your own race. And I really, I'm always encouraging people who listen to this, hey, take the principles and some of the tactics, but also like, don't just assume that because something worked for one of us or for one of the other high-profile e-commerce people, that it's gonna work exactly for you.
And a crazy stat. So in August, We, so of our, from a numbers perspective, we acquired 60% of last year's new customers in one month, last August.
That's amazing.
Because of that. And, uh, because there's just a lot of people at 3.2, there's way more people that want to try a brand for the first time.
Can you, okay, so contrast the personal learning with this, you started talking to your customers, is Is this where you learned to, maybe we should drop the price? From all that survey?
We did a customer survey and the basics and understanding the marketplace. There was just a lot of brands out there that sold a black t-shirt now. And so we didn't have to be the cheapest. We're still not, but we needed to provide more value to the customers to compete in that marketplace. And so like understanding where you sit in the marketplace, you do it when you start as a business, but then you, a lot of people after 4 or 5 years, they don't continually do like those charts and where do you sit? And the e-com game, you have to compare to e-com companies. Don't even look at the retail companies 'cause it's a way different customer behavior. So that was something, you know, when I, from a personal life, I got really introspective during that time. And then we also did that for the business.
That's great.
Of like, let's just rethink the business of how we're gonna be successful moving forward. And it was like, and it really just like our business is exploding again.
You know, there's a, Uh, we've all heard this term product-market fit, right? The problem is that markets move. Yeah, totally. It's not— Time changes markets.
It's not a static thing.
No. So just because you get it one year doesn't mean you get to keep it every year by default.
Well, look at Nike right now. You know, there's a point where Nike and Lulu had extreme product-market fit and they've fallen out of it. And that if you don't evolve and change as a company, as the market evolves and changes, you will fall out of product-market fit. So, one of the things you've mentioned several times, Stephen, is being quite introspective about your own leadership and about the company. What are 2 or 3 things you took from that, uh, that process of looking inward to, to get better and to run the company, to lead yourself more effectively?
Not saying I wanna go through that again, of that, you know, the mountains, but like, I gotta say, I'm super grateful for it. Like, I didn't know the business and the, the, the intimacy that I know it now. Um, I, like, the, the saying is, what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. But why that is true is because it, it has a way of, like, when you go through something that's really difficult, of showing you the, the inefficiencies that you couldn't see before. That's what a difficulty is. And so now when I, when I think about the future of Cuts, I am so excited because I feel like I know the iceberg's here. How do you avoid that iceberg? Um, and it, it gets me really, really excited to, you know, go over these next 8 years of like how big we can take this business.
Tell me about 2026. Obviously this is a comeback story. Mm-hmm. And the business is thriving again. How, what can you tell us about the business and where it is today?
Yeah, so, uh, we, right around November, December, I was like, I said, it's no longer the year of the cockroach. It's like, who gonna stop
me?
Let's, we're taking names and we're going for it. Uh, And it's time to go. And so we started, you know, very cautiously getting, hiring a little bit, getting some key members. We knew the funnel congruency was big. The Everyday Collection, we needed high replenishment, lots of colors. The Elevated Collection, we found our new acquisition winner, which was our Elevated Collection where we're spending a ton of money. Our— I'm so proud of our VP of Ops and VP of Marketing that they also became studs. Like they could be on the operators, uh, like marketing guys, 'cause they just know how to generate revenue through this period. Like they're studs too. Um, and we, we just, it's not that, uh, we're doing anything like crazy different. It's like we're just doing the basics well and then turning up the gas. Um, and a cool story about today specifically was a year ago today I was at this conference and I just had heard about about the, uh, the container going in the water. And I was staying in Greenwich Village and I walked to 83rd Street where this like church was. And I remember I was sitting in church, I was like, kind of like almost like tearing up, like, man, everything has gone wrong that could go wrong. Fast forward one year, like everything in my life has gotten better. Mm-hmm. My personal life is thriving. My, uh, business has, has never been more healthy and I can see such a bright future. And it's like, I almost want to scream it from the rooftops that if you're going through something very difficult, like a lot can change in a year, right foot, left foot, right foot, left foot, take it as a blessing, like as pure joy that you're given the opportunity to learn where your mistakes are. And this can be the catalyst for growing your business in a big way or anything in your personal life.
I love that idea. And I was talking with one of our team members. He had a really frustrating situation on Friday. We're going to launch a new brand. He had picked out everything. We had everything set up, and then we found out somebody had filed for the trademark like a week before we had, and we were going to have to totally go a new direction on the branding. And the pep talk I gave him was effectiveness as a person and as a leader is your, your initial reaction's gonna be you're super mad, you're super discouraged, you're super frustrated. It's how much can you shrink the window between when you find out and you're frustrated to when you move into solutions and you move into taking the right approach. And I think it's true for all of us that like, so easy, man, when the circumstances suck to just, uh, feel over— almost overwhelmed by 'em. Your story is one that, you know what you do? You find the right direction, you go left foot, right foot, and like you said, things can change a lot quicker than you would think that they could. Mm-hmm.
Go a little deeper on the, uh, this market is competitive. We've got more people now. We've had to be thoughtful about our customers, where we're positioned. You said you think the future is very bright. What is your durable competitive advantage? How are you thinking about where you guys position in this big sort of grid of a market?
Yeah. So, uh, if you think about like the, not demise, but like Lululemon and Nike, why they've fallen out, the, the super polyester Mm-hmm. Kind of everyday items of like really, really basics has fallen outta favor, uh, with, from a customer's acquisition standpoint. There's been 10 years of Lulu and how many brands have done that? And so we, we as Cuts has, our tagline has been for the sport of business. So yes, that's what business was when we were in, when we launched the brand, but it's no longer what you see like business people wearing to work. If you walk down the street in New York, I still see a lot of Cuts, but I also see a little bit more elevated collections coming out.
Sure, yeah.
So understanding that, that our tagline and our ethos of the business can adapt to that, that's gonna allow us to win that marketplace. And if you look at like a Suitsupply or Bruno Cucinelli that are much more expensive, can Cuts be the winner of that slightly lower price point? in the marketplace that I'm really excited about. And so that's where, that's the marketplace that we want to just own and win of, you know, that 26 to 35-year-old, you know, someone that really looks up to you guys. Are they going to wear cuts on an everyday basis? And we feel like we can win that better than anyone else.
Have you found products that do that, that like, that push you there?
So our Riviera collection and our SoHo collection inspired by New York City where we are today have done that really well where they're A little bit more textures, a little bit more depth to the products, and a lot more uniqueness in the algorithm. And this point is so important. When you're thinking about running an e-commerce business and from a competitive advantage, I always see, have I seen a lot of ads for this given product? That's your competition. So like the black t-shirt, we were the first game in town in 2017, 2018, 2019, more or less, maybe one or two other brands.
And in prints at first.
At first.
At first.
At first. So now we're always looking 2, 3 years down the line of what products could have a low CPM. So it means in the auction, there's not a lot of competition that are slightly different that we do know that fit those elevated collections. And that's where we want to, that's where we need to innovate because that's where we're going to get spend and that's where we're going to get growth. But it doesn't mean that black t-shirts in our everyday collection doesn't grow. It just doesn't mean we advertise on it. So like, uh, we don't need to advertise because we're known for it. So it, and this is how our business grows. We have our, our core everyday collection, and then we have our new innovation collections. As the innovation collection grows in spend where we get, you know, $10,000, $20,000, $30,000 a day on these new collections, it also lifts all boats in the business in this core stuff. And then that you get a lot of profit from the things that you're known But from an advertising perspective, you just can't get spend on those. So you don't want to lose money by spending on those earlier collections. And that's why I'm really excited about where Meta's at and where, uh, and how to grow a business is because we're only one step away from in, uh, from more innovation and unlocking another $20K in spend. And so like, if I was betting on businesses in the future, I'd bet on businesses that can do that really fast because Because it's so competitive now. You might find a winner in '26, by '28, you might not be able to spend on that. But what businesses can innovate that quick without reinventing the entire brand, without starting a new brand? Apparel. But you gotta know how to do it, right? So a lot of people say, is apparel a really hard business? Yes. But I think in this current environment, it's actually pretty advantageous.
That's very cool.
One observation I would make is your brand gets stronger every time you create a horizontal add-on.
Mm-hmm.
Because you have more monetization ability than a competitor. Yeah. And so we really have to do that. You have to find a way to moat your business and to seal out, like we launched Winx, within an hour there was a, there was counterfeit on Amazon. Instant. It's like an hour. Instant.
Yeah.
And so like we're living in a world.
Yeah.
Where like your ad, you know, your ad library is gonna be watched by 1,000 AI bots. Anything new that you're scaling spend on or that you're iterating on, they're gonna see And, and other people are gonna try it. So you need structural advantages. So I think you're right, like you've gotta be able to be bringing new innovation in that is unique, that is going to be able to drive acquisition. But then you also need a superior monetization engine on the backend where you can just outbid all the people that want to come in and compete with you. You gotta make those 10 years really work for you. Mm-hmm. And it sounds like you're doing it. Stephen, we end with a thing called the Titan 10. I'm gonna ask you 10 questions, rapid-fire style. Don't overthink this. You are on a desert island. A bottle, I can send you a bottle with a message in the bottle, and on that message are 3 metrics about your business. What do you wanna see?
Contribution margin and fixed cost, so I know what my profit is. And then, uh, I might say 4. That's fine. And then, and then my, uh, Uh, uh, CAC and my number of new customers versus returning.
All right.
Okay. Unfortunately, you didn't get the 4th because I only gave you 3, but okay. Uh, you can have one book or resource to read, but it can't be business related.
The one book that I would choose would be, and it can't be business, would be the Bible.
You have some contrarian beliefs. What is your most contrarian belief about business?
The most contrarian belief is that free shipping is a scam.
Uh,
we rarely do it anymore, but free shipping, it's a real cost in your business. It's gonna eat into your contribution margin, especially in apparel where there's return shipping, uh, you know, lost packages shipping, um, all, all of this stuff that, be careful with that because that just eats into your Like that could be 10% of your business and now you gotta be 20. It just makes it so much harder to drive profit.
Mike Beckham: Mm-hmm. I can't count the number of people in the last couple years who have done tests and decided charging more for shipping or starting to charge for shipping is the right move for their business. What is the single most important word in leadership?
Sign me up. Like, I think a lot of times founders, as they start to have success, They like, uh, don't want to start the project. And for me, what I've learned is I want to do like the first 15% of any new initiative and really learn it because I need to be able to give direction to it. And, uh, if I'm not like getting my hands, hands dirty, I just don't think you can be successful with, in the current market where everything's changing so fast, where I need to be in the first 15 and the last 15%. I think it's so, so important. Mm-hmm. But, uh, uh, you know, that's why I'm always, I'm always in shock with founders and maybe you guys are there, but that are maybe more away from the business.
Yeah,
I think like that's a recipe of disaster.
Gotta get your fingers dirty.
What's the single most important word in business?
Cash
flow. From like someone who's experienced not having cash flow.
What's the best meal of the day, your day, and why?
I used to say breakfast, but I love a good dinner when I get home.
Right now, what do you think's the most overrated growth tactic you see people talking about?
Volume creative for volume creative's sake.
No.
I think there's, 'cause we have a ton of creative, like 8,000 pieces of creative a month that has fueled a lot of our growth, but when it's just volume of like crap that, that doesn't work. So it's gotta fit that funnel, uh, very well, or it's not something that will actually drive incremental growth. And if anything, it could clog up your ad account and just create more problems for you.
Mm-hmm.
Absolutely. So what's the most underrated tactic?
I'm gonna steal this one from, uh, Zach, but, uh, funnel congruency.
Hell yeah.
Awesome. So, so you once said a business only dies when a founder runs out of energy. How's your energy level?
I feel like when problems happen, it only recharges you when you come over the mountain, 'cause you get over it and you realize, man, I just came through a lot. And my new saying this year is, send another arrow. Send another one.
I love it. Well, as many people who, uh, are in my day-to-day life could tell you, I wear a lot of cuts. Uh, actually, like during the period where you were really going through it, we were talking pretty frequently. And, uh, I am so proud of you and the way that you've fought through adversity, uh, and the way that you've done it with character. And it is so awesome to hear your story. I really appreciate you sharing, uh, not just the peaks, but also the valleys with us because it helps all of us to get better.
Love it. Appreciate being here. And, uh, my favorite pod is Operators Pod, the Titans. Love you guys. I learned so much.